WEBVTT

1
00:00:00.000 --> 00:00:17.000
Alright, I think that's the end of the technical Reminders that I have for today so at this time I wanted to turn the floor over to Emmy Laha to offer an introduction to this session so Emmy

2
00:00:17.000 --> 00:00:21.000
Perfect. Thank you so much Jean so just very quickly.

3
00:00:21.000 --> 00:00:26.000
I want to talk about the Federal Facilities Academy. As Jean mentioned earlier, this is the last Webinar.

4
00:00:26.000 --> 00:00:27.000
For this series, we plan to offer and update these webinars about every 2 years.

5
00:00:27.000 --> 00:00:32.000
I'm gonna add you here to the spotlight, and I'll turn the floor to you to talk a bit about

6
00:00:32.000 --> 00:00:47.000
So if you participate in all of the 11 webinars and an in-person class, you can get a certificate of completion for the Academy and Gene will give details on how to get your certificates for that in a second but the program itself was developed for

7
00:00:47.000 --> 00:01:04.000
EPA Remedial Project Managers, Rpms from other Federal Agencies as well as our State and Tribal Partners, so it's really open to everyone Who's involved in Federal Facility Clean Ups, and these Webinars Try to get to the Nuances, of Federal Facilities, because

8
00:01:04.000 --> 00:01:09.000
Although the cleanup is happening under circle it. Can be just a little bit.

9
00:01:09.000 --> 00:01:12.000
Different. So that's the goal of these 11 webinars.

10
00:01:12.000 --> 00:01:13.000
And I thank you so much for joining us

11
00:01:13.000 --> 00:01:14.000
Alright. Thank you so much. Emmy, so I will just remind the audience here that they can receive credit for each and every one of the online webinars that they may participate in as part of the ongoing series so again, there were 11 of those webinars you can either take them live or you can

12
00:01:14.000 --> 00:01:17.000
Replay any or all of them, as archived version, and again, you can mix and match and complete any or all, of the Webinars in any Combination of those formats, as Needed, these are open to the Public and then as emmy Highlighted there is a In-person, Three-day Delivery, although I

13
00:01:17.000 --> 00:01:18.000
Believe as Emmy was highlighting in other classes.

14
00:01:18.000 --> 00:01:22.000
I think they have done an online version of it at 1 point so I say in person.

15
00:01:22.000 --> 00:01:41.000
But please know that there may have been situational requirements that required that 3 day or longer class to be delivered in a different format but that was restricted to EPA states tribes and other Federal agencies, so you could only attend that singular delivery at the time, of a live delivery if you were in one

16
00:01:41.000 --> 00:01:45.000
of those focused groups and as Emmy Highlighted.

17
00:01:45.000 --> 00:01:47.000
You can receive a certificate for any or all of the online webinars.

18
00:01:47.000 --> 00:02:03.000
And then if you do all 11, no matter whether you took them all online, all recorded as replayed or some combination of them, and you completed that three-day course then you can receive that academy certificate for the entire series so I'll, cover instructions at the close of our

19
00:02:03.000 --> 00:02:10.000
Session, today on how you can share your feedback to get a participation certificate for today's course, but without taking up any more time.

20
00:02:10.000 --> 00:02:14.000
Emmy, I think we should jump right into the class, shall we?

21
00:02:14.000 --> 00:02:15.000
So I will turn to you to begin the screen share. I will take my video off.

22
00:02:15.000 --> 00:02:27.000
The screens, since I'm gonna turn the floor over to you, to officially, start today's session

23
00:02:27.000 --> 00:02:54.000
And the slides are great.

24
00:02:54.000 --> 00:03:00.000
Perfect, thank you so much. Okay, glad to see that They're up and rolling.

25
00:03:00.000 --> 00:03:02.000
So we'll go ahead and jump into today into today's content again, my name is Emmy.

26
00:03:02.000 --> 00:03:21.000
Leiha, I'm with our Federal facilities. Restoration, and Reuse office at EPA, Headquarters, and today we're going to be talking about avrars, so before we jump into all the content I would like to get a better sense, of Who's Joining Us, today, so a quick group Poll no

27
00:03:21.000 --> 00:03:43.000
writer, wrong, answer. No worries. But if you could just type in the chat what experience you have had with ars in a decision document at a Federal facility is it none or a little or you've helped identify arors or perhaps you haven't Touched them at all and whatever it is I

28
00:03:43.000 --> 00:03:49.000
just wanna get a sense of how a rar. Familiar, we are on today's Webinar.

29
00:03:49.000 --> 00:03:50.000
Alright and Emmy. I'm starting to see those responses coming into the Q, and a.

30
00:03:50.000 --> 00:03:51.000
So okay.

31
00:03:51.000 --> 00:04:10.000
So remember you'll be sharing your response to Emmy's pull question here, just by writing it into the Q, and a later on.

32
00:04:10.000 --> 00:04:11.000
Hmm, okay.

33
00:04:11.000 --> 00:04:17.000
We'll have separate pop-up windows. But for this one, you'll just type it directly into the Q, and a and submit that response and so as I scan through a number of people have had no Experience, in this area at all some have been in dispute over a rars others have updated

34
00:04:17.000 --> 00:04:20.000
them through a five-year review process. In some cases, they were involved in identifying A Rars.

35
00:04:20.000 --> 00:04:32.000
Some have even helped develop the arars. We do have a number of people who have written Dds and rods.

36
00:04:32.000 --> 00:04:36.000
Again, it looks like most of the people who have worked with them.

37
00:04:36.000 --> 00:04:45.000
Have either used them in their 5 year reviews, or have simply had done that selection and identification process, as I'm reading through these responses

38
00:04:45.000 --> 00:04:46.000
Oh, right. So we have quite A, a spectrum of people today.

39
00:04:46.000 --> 00:05:04.000
We have no experience to have to go to dispute on an aar, so that's great, this will be either a great refresher or a first time webinar, for you all so let's go ahead, and switch over to our Overview, I'm gonna ask deidra to join us

40
00:05:04.000 --> 00:05:12.000
On video, introduce, herself and get us started with today's content

41
00:05:12.000 --> 00:05:18.000
Hi. My name's Deidre Lloyd, and I Am Emmy and I Teach the three-day class together.

42
00:05:18.000 --> 00:05:32.000
A lot with a couple of other instructors. And we really enjoy that love all the questions and the input, and every time we do the class we update it with additions, or deletions, with what you don't like what you do like so we're happy to see all of you here, today, and i'm

43
00:05:32.000 --> 00:05:35.000
just gonna give a brief overview for the first time, 13.

44
00:05:35.000 --> 00:05:52.000
Or so slides and then we'll have different people come on and we'll go onto more, detail later, on so the Overview, Errors, and to be considered so that's applicable or Relevant and Appropriate Requirements and there are 3, different types of arors, we Hope that you'll be familiar

45
00:05:52.000 --> 00:06:08.000
with at the end of this class, and We want we hope you'll be able to understand the difference between substantive and administrative requirements and how to document aars and then how to identify arors, and then the procedures, you go through to analyze the Ars, for use

46
00:06:08.000 --> 00:06:21.000
later on in your Rod and throughout the whole Circle Process. And then we also hope that you'll be familiar with the 6 types of AR, waivers

47
00:06:21.000 --> 00:06:28.000
So we're gonna talk about arars and TV scenes.

48
00:06:28.000 --> 00:06:44.000
So why are aros necessary at all circle was enacted 1,900, and 80 to address abandoned Uncontrolled Hazardous Way Sites and this Includes Emergency Responses Removals, Both Time Critical and Non Time Critical Remedial Actions, and All the Way.

49
00:06:44.000 --> 00:06:52.000
to Long term Monitoring on a Circle Site no permits are Required for Onsite work, and

50
00:06:52.000 --> 00:07:12.000
The reason that was the purpose for that is to avoid linky permitting processes applications, and then the associated fees and all this was done To Expedite Site Cleanup but Permits, even though you Don't have to get the actual Permit document, or pay a Fee you still need to be Compliant

51
00:07:12.000 --> 00:07:28.000
with the substantive portions of the Permit and so again, the reason for the no permitting is to expedite cleanup, and while you remain protective of human health, in the environment.

52
00:07:28.000 --> 00:07:45.000
Right, so overview, our onsite circle cleanups, we all we must attain or wave, an aer, there's no in between us either retain it, if it's in the rod or have a basis, for waving the aer and they should be after you've identified

53
00:07:45.000 --> 00:07:54.000
Them and in your rod, you you you must comply with the ars throughout your Circle process, and Circle Section 121 d.

54
00:07:54.000 --> 00:08:01.000
Requires that all site, remedial actions, again, either attainer Web under limited circumstances.

55
00:08:01.000 --> 00:08:17.000
You may want to think about some local requirements that may be a r such as maybe releasing to your local sewage, if you if you treat groundwater, you know that's been contaminated or if it's clean enough that's something you may want to include they're

56
00:08:17.000 --> 00:08:23.000
Very site-specific. So you have to consider your your what you have going on in site, and so it takes it takes a little while.

57
00:08:23.000 --> 00:08:32.000
But the better you understand yourself more able you will be to apply the ars, and there are many different sources for aros.

58
00:08:32.000 --> 00:08:40.000
You can use the clean water act. You consider ripra resource conservation, recovery, act, safe, drinking, water, act, clean air at it.

59
00:08:40.000 --> 00:08:49.000
But you may be located in the flood plane. And that's going to guide some of your decisions, or you may even have some wetlands nearby.

60
00:08:49.000 --> 00:09:08.000
Okay. So some of the state requirements, They must be in order for to be in a r applicable they must be promulgated, and all that means is they must be outlined in an enforceable state, statute or regulation and they must be more stringent, than the Federal laws, and they must be

61
00:09:08.000 --> 00:09:30.000
Identified, by the State in a timely manner, so that's, the consultation process when you if you work at the State and EPA and the Lead Agency Excuse me Adam Brain Moment but anyway, so all 3 Should Work Together, and Consult, one another and you know Discuss your Errors but

62
00:09:30.000 --> 00:09:38.000
There's a time you need to do it in timely, manner and the State must consistently apply or demonstrate intention to consistently.

63
00:09:38.000 --> 00:09:44.000
Apply, this, whatever, the Identified requirement is at similar sites throughout the State.

64
00:09:44.000 --> 00:09:55.000
So there's also and expectation that there's some consistency even after they're problemated

65
00:09:55.000 --> 00:10:02.000
Alright next one is to be considered tbcs, and these by definition are not promulgated.

66
00:10:02.000 --> 00:10:21.000
They're Usually Advisories, or Guidance that have been issued by a the Federal or State, Government, or sometimes even another Agency, maybe Dod, or do and so these will be considered along with ars throughout the process you could you'll, look at your Site, risk assessment, your risk assessor will Assess.

67
00:10:21.000 --> 00:10:26.000
You know, risk to human health in the environment and that will guide some of your Tbcs,

68
00:10:26.000 --> 00:10:31.000
And then you determine the necessary level of cleanup and the Tbcs.

69
00:10:31.000 --> 00:10:50.000
Can be included in the rod. If they are deemed necessary and they help to support the auror or determined your prg is your preliminary remediation, goals, so you can consider them throughout the Process, and they should not be Propagated, and maybe something that might

70
00:10:50.000 --> 00:10:55.000
Be a one. You might think about is a fish advisory, and that you know you might have one.

71
00:10:55.000 --> 00:10:58.000
When you start your site. But if you clean it up and go along.

72
00:10:58.000 --> 00:11:01.000
It may not be necessary to include it in the rod, because it's already been cleaned up.

73
00:11:01.000 --> 00:11:15.000
Or alternatively, if it's not you may want to keep that fish advisory, and then have some caveats in your rod about you know how to handle it as it's a site, cleanup goes on and a good resource is EPA's overview of the Ars fact

74
00:11:15.000 --> 00:11:35.000
Sheet, and then I think any handed out some other resources Links, and so the Tbc should be considered optimally during your Feasibility study and your proposed plan and then once you select a remedial Action then you can include your Tbcs in the Rod

75
00:11:35.000 --> 00:11:39.000
And your Tbc is like I said you would consider them throughout the process and think some will drop out, and some will be retained.

76
00:11:39.000 --> 00:11:45.000
Or you may have none, but that's the the your thought process.

77
00:11:45.000 --> 00:11:49.000
You should be thinking about as you. Go along

78
00:11:49.000 --> 00:11:53.000
And if you include a tbc in a rod, then it is also applicable.

79
00:11:53.000 --> 00:12:02.000
And you have to make sure that you enforce that, and that you live by your Tbcs also alright, so identification of Irrs.

80
00:12:02.000 --> 00:12:17.000
This is considered very early in the circle process, in the reason being an april, may may affect your sampling approach or some of the Analytical methods, or some of your method detection, limits, that you're going to use throughout your medial Investigation so the earlier you consider

81
00:12:17.000 --> 00:12:37.000
Them, and identify them as potential arors that will guide your remedial investigation going forward and they must be must be sites for s site, specific and they involve, a 2 part analysis is it, applicable or is it relevant and appropriate it cannot be both and they again.

82
00:12:37.000 --> 00:12:45.000
Arose must be based on site, specific circumstances.

83
00:12:45.000 --> 00:13:03.000
Alright, applicable. Again, They're Promulgated Under Federal State, Statute, Law Regulation, and they specifically address the Contaminants On Site, whether they be a Pollutant, Contaminant Or a Hazardous Substance, sometimes they You'll consider them, the Applicable Requirements.

84
00:13:03.000 --> 00:13:17.000
You definitely should consider them during a remedial action. They sometimes site specific locations will matter Wetlands, Sighting, facility issues, and then the Lead and Support Agencies will identify the requirements.

85
00:13:17.000 --> 00:13:26.000
That are applicable to the release or the remedial action

86
00:13:26.000 --> 00:13:34.000
And so applicable. You must always think about the substantive environmental protection requirements that are propagated by Federal and state laws and it's going to involve you should involve your legal Counsel early in the Process too.

87
00:13:34.000 --> 00:13:38.000
Because they'll help help determine a Rars and Right into your decision.

88
00:13:38.000 --> 00:13:50.000
Document, how and why they're relevant and why applicable

89
00:13:50.000 --> 00:13:54.000
Alright.

90
00:13:54.000 --> 00:13:56.000
Some of the relevant and appropriate requirements.

91
00:13:56.000 --> 00:14:10.000
So these are going to address they're going to be there, if they're relevant and appropriate, then they're not applicable, so they're going to Address Situations on Site, They're, going to Address, some of your Site Specific Situations, on Site, and They you Can Look at

92
00:14:10.000 --> 00:14:18.000
Some Promulgated Cleanup standards, and you can pick some things out of there, but an example of like standards for your cleanup.

93
00:14:18.000 --> 00:14:19.000
If you have a uranium or authorium processing facility, this might, this is a good example.

94
00:14:19.000 --> 00:14:30.000
While your site may be a uranium mining site, so it's not a processing facility, some of their standards.

95
00:14:30.000 --> 00:14:47.000
Can you can pick out ones that apply to your site specifics, criteria that you're dealing with on Site you know, your uranium tailings or something they may they may have some site, specific standards, that you can pull out of there and use for a relevant and

96
00:14:47.000 --> 00:14:51.000
Appropriate requirement.

97
00:14:51.000 --> 00:14:59.000
Oh! Great example was that the Mcl's may not be applicable to a groundwater cleanup, but they are definitely relevant and appropriate.

98
00:14:59.000 --> 00:15:06.000
So always have them sales well, always is a bad word, but most of the time I can't think of an example.

99
00:15:06.000 --> 00:15:17.000
When you wouldn't have in Cls. Al Alright, Relevant and Appropriate continued a determination that a really that requirement is relevant and appropriate again.

100
00:15:17.000 --> 00:15:18.000
Consider both so if we hit this 3 times, you're guessing that it's important.

101
00:15:18.000 --> 00:15:38.000
So, and these are onely based on professional judgment and your professional judgment comes in for your site, specific, when you're going to apply these sites specifically, and the more you know about your site, the more familiar you are the better able you are going to be able to compare the requirements with your site.

102
00:15:38.000 --> 00:15:43.000
Specific needs and the following side is going to have a comparison of some things.

103
00:15:43.000 --> 00:15:47.000
You should think about. When you're looking, considering, relevant appropriate,

104
00:15:47.000 --> 00:16:03.000
So the professional judgment as mentioned is important, and you need to have a deep understanding of your site, specific circumstances activities and think about your remedial Alumni, when You're considering your relevant and appropriate Requirements, because They'll Influence How You're Going to Address your

105
00:16:03.000 --> 00:16:06.000
Contamination on Site. What Medium is contaminated? What substances?

106
00:16:06.000 --> 00:16:10.000
Are you dealing with what's the purpose of your circle action?

107
00:16:10.000 --> 00:16:12.000
Are you gonna do a removal? Are you going to clean up brown water?

108
00:16:12.000 --> 00:16:20.000
Are you going clean up soil, and these inform your relevant appropriate requirements, going, forward, and so look at your alternatives.

109
00:16:20.000 --> 00:16:36.000
And you can your tbcs and your arors may drop out as you go along, and your remedial investigation matures, but for instance and I'm not going to go over all 8 of these but for instance, A medium, Regulated by Requirement if You're, looking at a requirement, to

110
00:16:36.000 --> 00:16:41.000
Determine, Relevant and appropriate that you would say it must apply to the soil.

111
00:16:41.000 --> 00:16:44.000
If your medium is soil and it's contaminated at the Site.

112
00:16:44.000 --> 00:16:57.000
If you're going to clean up groundwater and there's no soil that needs to be cleaned up, then that might not be the best requirement, for you and the same for the rest, of them so We want to make sure that whatever requirement you're considering that it is definitely relevant

113
00:16:57.000 --> 00:17:06.000
To your site, and it's appropriate to use that particular requirement

114
00:17:06.000 --> 00:17:09.000
Thanks Ddra one thing I wanna mention here in the first column, where we have the characteristics of the requirement that is, paraphrase.

115
00:17:09.000 --> 00:17:18.000
But it's essentially the language used in the Ncp.

116
00:17:18.000 --> 00:17:36.000
And then in the second Column, where We're talking about Surpla just trying to get the language, into something that might make a little more sense. As you're considering your Site, but We're gonna go ahead, and go into a quick hold quiz if you will Jean will you take us through this

117
00:17:36.000 --> 00:17:41.000
Absolutely, I will. So I'm going to pop up a new window on the screen, and let me hit the button.

118
00:17:41.000 --> 00:17:51.000
Now you all should see a box asking you which of the following is not true of a tbc is it a.

119
00:17:51.000 --> 00:17:55.000
It is promulgated. B it is not propagated C.

120
00:17:55.000 --> 00:17:59.000
It is considered in determining a r Remedy's Protectiveness or D.

121
00:17:59.000 --> 00:18:14.000
It can help determine preliminary remediation, goals you'll see a Circle next to each one of those options, simply click the circle, to the left of the answer that you believe to be correct, and then hit the Submit Button, and then that will cast your vote, in meanwhile back here, I

122
00:18:14.000 --> 00:18:17.000
Can see the distribution? And how many of you have voted.

123
00:18:17.000 --> 00:18:21.000
So about half of you have sent your answers in remember, this is meant to help our instructors.

124
00:18:21.000 --> 00:18:31.000
Understand where you are in comprehension, and if they need to revisit some concept, so there's no penalty for getting it wrong, take your best guests, and then hit that submit Button I think, I have spent enough time.

125
00:18:31.000 --> 00:18:56.000
Here waiting to get those answers coming in so I'm gonna go and close that pole in 3, 2, one, and now, looking at it, Emmy, it looks like about two-thirds of the Eyes, picked a it is Promulgated that is not true. For a Tbc is that the right answer

126
00:18:56.000 --> 00:18:57.000
Alright Excellent

127
00:18:57.000 --> 00:18:59.000
That is the right answer. Yes. We were looking for a as the answer to this question, if it's promo, and I, I, it was like a double negative.

128
00:18:59.000 --> 00:19:02.000
So I could understand why people might have chosen be thinking.

129
00:19:02.000 --> 00:19:07.000
Yeah, Tbc is not promulgated. But the question is if it's not true.

130
00:19:07.000 --> 00:19:10.000
So sorry if you guys, the grammar caught you on that one

131
00:19:10.000 --> 00:19:27.000
Excell excellent, and I mean. We do have some new students, or brand new people, and I just wanted to share one quick definition, if you're not familiar with the term Rod or Acronym our od it stands for Record of decision, so please if you hear a Phrase, or a term.

132
00:19:27.000 --> 00:19:29.000
That you're not familiar with, let us know in the Q.

133
00:19:29.000 --> 00:19:32.000
And a will be sure to define it for you. Alright, let me go ahead

134
00:19:32.000 --> 00:19:35.000
Oh, but we have another quiz question. Jean

135
00:19:35.000 --> 00:19:41.000
Oh, boy, all right, let me go and launch this one, so you'll see a new pop up on the screen.

136
00:19:41.000 --> 00:19:44.000
And this, is a scenario, where we ask you to apply your understanding.

137
00:19:44.000 --> 00:20:02.000
In this case site, y identifies, a facility, that was used for plutonium processing and is Radiologically Contaminated remediation will Address Contaminated Buildings, and Soil So We're asking you which of the following Standards, could be considered Relevant and Appropriate for this

138
00:20:02.000 --> 00:20:06.000
Remedial action. And in this answer or this question, you can select all that apply.

139
00:20:06.000 --> 00:20:10.000
So you'll see a box to the left of each of these Options.

140
00:20:10.000 --> 00:20:27.000
So you can select any or all, so is it option a record, closure, and post-closure performance, standards for a waste management, unit, Option, B record requirements, for tank, systems, including response to leaks or Spills, Option, C standards, for Cleanup, of other Radiologically, Contaminated.

141
00:20:27.000 --> 00:20:39.000
Sites, such as uranium and thorium processing facilities, or option, d nuclear, Regulatory Commission Regulations for Low-level, Waste Transfer, or Display, If You're having Any Problems with that Q.

142
00:20:39.000 --> 00:20:40.000
And a or probably with a poll window. You can always type, a response in the Q.

143
00:20:40.000 --> 00:20:59.000
A if that's the only way, but as I'm looking through here, it looks like about a third of the audience has shared their thoughts, or remember you can check one or 2, or 3, or all of the Boxes if you think they all apply and then hit that submit Button once you've selected

144
00:20:59.000 --> 00:21:03.000
Your responses, from those options and I'm gonna go ahead.

145
00:21:03.000 --> 00:21:09.000
And close these responses. Here is about three-quarters of you have voted.

146
00:21:09.000 --> 00:21:25.000
So we'll close it in 3, 2. One. Alright, and in looking at it, it looks like the audience, about 3 over 4 of Them, Picked Cnd, but almost two-thirds Picked, a so Emmy what are the right answers

147
00:21:25.000 --> 00:21:26.000
So the answers we were looking for in this question were C.

148
00:21:26.000 --> 00:21:30.000
And d granted a. And B might apply. We don't have all the details of the facility.

149
00:21:30.000 --> 00:21:53.000
So we would have to consider those to see if a reporter closure Requirements Or tanks, systems might be included in this facility, but again, for the example and the limited information you were given in this question, we were looking for c and D since you have this radiologically.

150
00:21:53.000 --> 00:22:01.000
Contaminated. Media. It makes sense that C. And D. Could be ars for your cleanup.

151
00:22:01.000 --> 00:22:03.000
Alright Excellent Thanks Emmy

152
00:22:03.000 --> 00:22:09.000
Alright well, I hope those questions were helpful there. I mean the second one was a little harder right trying to get you.

153
00:22:09.000 --> 00:22:14.000
Some apply the information. We've gone over so far, but we're gonna switch gears a bit.

154
00:22:14.000 --> 00:22:19.000
And talk about the different types of Arors. So we have 3, different types.

155
00:22:19.000 --> 00:22:39.000
They can be chemical, location, or action, specific ars with the chemical, specific and location specific ones, those are typically identified early in the circle, process, so we're talking about as early as the site investigation, and those chemical, specific Avars are usually Health or Risk-based, Numerical

156
00:22:39.000 --> 00:22:40.000
Values and with location specific as the name entails.

157
00:22:40.000 --> 00:22:41.000
You're looking at actions in a specific location.

158
00:22:41.000 --> 00:22:51.000
But we're going to go over all of these in more detail, the following slides for your app specific, a rars.

159
00:22:51.000 --> 00:22:55.000
Those are identified during the feasibility study, which makes sense, you have.

160
00:22:55.000 --> 00:23:16.000
To look at what alternatives are being considered to know which requirements may apply so let's jump into each of these with our chemical, specific a right, again, you're looking at usually a health or risk based numerical value, or methodology and a great example, that we've mentioned, already before are our numerical

161
00:23:16.000 --> 00:23:20.000
Mcls Maximum Contaminant levels for groundwater.

162
00:23:20.000 --> 00:23:28.000
That is identified as a potential source of drinking water, those Mcls identify What's in Appropriate level of Acceptable risk.

163
00:23:28.000 --> 00:23:31.000
And those with the numbers you would have to meet in that case again, you have to also consider site specific.

164
00:23:31.000 --> 00:23:52.000
Information, when looking at those values and it's basically going to establish a value, that it has an acceptable amount or concentration of a chemical, that became f excuse me that can be found in or discharged to the ambient, environment, so if there's for example if there's not a

165
00:23:52.000 --> 00:24:07.000
Numerical value like Mcl, We're like them, that's an Ncl, you know what it is, but if there's not an Mcl, that exists, then you're going to have to look at the site specific exposure, Pathways concentration Amounts, and identify what the risk is.

166
00:24:07.000 --> 00:24:11.000
To be able to move forward here is an example in a record of decision.

167
00:24:11.000 --> 00:24:15.000
This was a cleanup decision at the Travis, Air Force base from 2014.

168
00:24:15.000 --> 00:24:19.000
And let me try and get my laser, pointer here.

169
00:24:19.000 --> 00:24:29.000
Oh, alright! So you can see this table specifically identifies it's for chemical, specific, Ars, this section of the table in the Citation.

170
00:24:29.000 --> 00:24:39.000
You can see it gets very specific with 4 Dcfr parts oh, it's a little small there, once 41, so we're in your citations.

171
00:24:39.000 --> 00:24:58.000
You do want to get us specific as possible. You don't want to cite the entire safe drinking water actor, the entire clean water act you want to get down to those sections, that directly apply to the conditions, at your site, this is a Federal requirement in this example and it's been identified as relevant

172
00:24:58.000 --> 00:25:17.000
And appropriate. So the Description provides more information on why the Supplies, and then any additional Comments, the Agencies Perhaps wanted to include are in this column, here, so this is one example of how you can do your a Rush Table it can vary from Rod to Rod but all this

173
00:25:17.000 --> 00:25:41.000
Information, no Matter, the Format should be included. Here is another example of chemical specific arars in this case, We're, looking at a State Requirement sources, of drinking water policy and this is from the State Water Resources control Board and It's Identified as a Tbc so again, a Federal

174
00:25:41.000 --> 00:25:49.000
Requirement in a state. Tbc, as examples so let's talk about action-specific requirements.

175
00:25:49.000 --> 00:25:54.000
Now at this point you are looking at your potential alternatives, your into your fs.

176
00:25:54.000 --> 00:26:00.000
So you're looking at technology, or activity based requirements, or limitations.

177
00:26:00.000 --> 00:26:01.000
And these are gonna help determine how remedial action must be achieved.

178
00:26:01.000 --> 00:26:23.000
So some examples, if you have a remedy that includes airstripping or capping, or injection of treated groundwater, there are going to be specific arors associated with those Actions all with the intent of protecting human health and the environment, so coming back to our travis

179
00:26:23.000 --> 00:26:31.000
Air Force, base, rod, Example, action, specific a bars listed here, the Requests is regarding Effluent requirements for Discharge to surface water, that is in 40 cfr, part 100. And 22.

180
00:26:31.000 --> 00:26:54.000
That relates to national, Polluted discharge elimination system, that Mpdes systems which typically require a permanent but under a Circle action you do 9 to get a permit but you have to meet the requirements, such as affluent requirements, before

181
00:26:54.000 --> 00:26:57.000
Discharge and here this is identified as applicable.

182
00:26:57.000 --> 00:27:05.000
Because you are directly discharging to surface water. So it directly

183
00:27:05.000 --> 00:27:09.000
Alright, so with location specific requirements. The name tells you.

184
00:27:09.000 --> 00:27:25.000
If you're looking at something where your cleanup is happening in a flood, plane, a wetland, historical places or places with sensitive de ecosystems or Habitats, you're gonna need, to look at these locations, specific requirements, so restrictions, are placed on the concentration of

185
00:27:25.000 --> 00:27:26.000
Hazardous substances, or the conduct of activities, solely because they occur in a special location.

186
00:27:26.000 --> 00:27:39.000
These locations, specific requirements usually may have a narrative description for the requirements rather than specifying a specific cleanup.

187
00:27:39.000 --> 00:27:47.000
Number. And this is where it becomes very important to consult with the appropriate agencies.

188
00:27:47.000 --> 00:28:05.000
Who can help ensure that you are in compliance with that err and we'll talk more about which agencies you should reach out to later in the slides, but let's look at an example of a location specific a rar from that same 24 team record of decision so here, we have

189
00:28:05.000 --> 00:28:16.000
An requirement for the endangered species act, that is a Federal requirement, and it's identified as app applicable and again that's looking to see if this Cleanup or Activities at the remedial sites must be performed in such a manner as to Identify the presence.

190
00:28:16.000 --> 00:28:32.000
Of and Protect endangered or Threatened plants and animals at the site. So there it is endangered species, act

191
00:28:32.000 --> 00:28:51.000
So what about at our Federal facility decision documents? When you're looking at that remedial process to get to a rod, it really has a combined effort by your Federal facility agreement party so that likely Includes, EPA the lead Cleanup Agency which is the other Federal Agency, and your State

192
00:28:51.000 --> 00:28:54.000
Partners, and it's not a one and done as we've mentioned.

193
00:28:54.000 --> 00:29:11.000
This occurs throughout the Circle Process from Site Investigation to issuance of that Cleanup Decision document in the Rod, so it's important to identify Ars that are Pertinent to the Characteristics of the Site the Specific Substances Present and the Potential Remedial Action

194
00:29:11.000 --> 00:29:19.000
Alternatives, being looked at what I'm trying to say is you cannot simply copy and paste arars from another Rod.

195
00:29:19.000 --> 00:29:37.000
That was previously issued, even if that's on the same Site, because it might have different characteristics, the Geology could be different the Groundwater could behave differently so Don't, Copy and Paste in Ars Table that the previous Person, At your Site, Use, because it might not be right

196
00:29:37.000 --> 00:29:40.000
for, what, you're looking at. Keep that in mind

197
00:29:40.000 --> 00:29:53.000
Another thing. Sometimes we get requests to for EPA to identify a Rars far in advance, like, just tell us, what we need to do so we can make sure that we're meeting it.

198
00:29:53.000 --> 00:30:09.000
As a cleanup agency, and you know, EPA can not specify in advance for sure, for certain which requirements will be a rash for our site, granted some of them are going to be pretty obvious but there are varied and unpredictable situations, that happen so EPA won't

199
00:30:09.000 --> 00:30:15.000
Be able, to say oh, absolutely, this is gonna be enabled, or this is not gonna be an error.

200
00:30:15.000 --> 00:30:18.000
You have to go through the process, and it's an iterative process.

201
00:30:18.000 --> 00:30:22.000
So it can change over time. Just something to keep in mind

202
00:30:22.000 --> 00:30:30.000
Okay, it's that time again, we we have a little, apply your understanding quiz for you, all

203
00:30:30.000 --> 00:30:47.000
Alright so, Emmy, I am launching this next question and we're going to talk about the Scenario, in this Particular Scenario, you are considering an institute groundwater remediation Approach for your Site how would you Label, the State's Groundwater policy that the ground, Water is considered

204
00:30:47.000 --> 00:30:56.000
A potential source of drinking water. Would you say a tbc, be applicable see relevant, and Appropriate, or D.

205
00:30:56.000 --> 00:31:14.000
None of the above, so simply click, that circle to the left of your answer, and then go ahead and hit the submit, I will also point out that I do have a number of questions that are coming into the Queue, and I just wanted to thank the audience for chiming in and Sharing, in their Questions

206
00:31:14.000 --> 00:31:17.000
And comments. We will pause in just a little while and get to them.

207
00:31:17.000 --> 00:31:20.000
So keep them coming in. That's exactly. What we want you to do with that Q&A.

208
00:31:20.000 --> 00:31:25.000
Space Emmy, it looks like about two-thirds of the Audience, or so have responded here.

209
00:31:25.000 --> 00:31:32.000
So I'll just give them another few seconds, and then I'll count down to closing the pole here, and 3, 2, one.

210
00:31:32.000 --> 00:31:37.000
And let's look at that. So it looks like B got a little bit more than a about a third of the audience.

211
00:31:37.000 --> 00:31:45.000
Picked to be about a third of them, picked a in almost, a third picked. C.

212
00:31:45.000 --> 00:31:49.000
So it looks like. This was the stumper question. What's the right answer

213
00:31:49.000 --> 00:32:03.000
So in this question, we were looking for a if it's the State's water policy, and it's not here we're assuming that word policy is the hint that it's not promulgated, so if It's not promulgated then it can't be Applicable, or

214
00:32:03.000 --> 00:32:10.000
relevant and appropriate. It can only be considered as a Tbc.

215
00:32:10.000 --> 00:32:15.000
So if people have Information or feedback on that specific question, like, no, that's not.

216
00:32:15.000 --> 00:32:28.000
How I understood it feel free to put that in your feedback form, or in the chat. That would be great to know but yes, that we were looking for a Tbc. On that one because it's not promulgated

217
00:32:28.000 --> 00:32:33.000
Okay, and sort of we do have a quick just definition check.

218
00:32:33.000 --> 00:32:37.000
Can we revisit the term tbc, what does that mean before we go any further

219
00:32:37.000 --> 00:32:40.000
That is to be considered

220
00:32:40.000 --> 00:32:52.000
Okay, all right, Alright and so Emmy I do. Have. A couple of people who are chiming in that their case, state waterboard resolutions are clickable, and their Water Board Resolutions are promulgated

221
00:32:52.000 --> 00:33:01.000
Okay, very good. Example. If it is promulgated, then it can be considered as an aer, or not only as a Tbc.

222
00:33:01.000 --> 00:33:10.000
So that's a great example. Maybe I have to we'll have to put in promulgated or not on that question, too, for the next time around thank you for that now I'm gonna hand it.

223
00:33:10.000 --> 00:33:11.000
You're right.

224
00:33:11.000 --> 00:33:20.000
Over to deidre, and she's going to talk to us about substantive and administrative requirements

225
00:33:20.000 --> 00:33:29.000
Hi again, Substantive and Administrative Requirements, what we're gonna chat about quickly.

226
00:33:29.000 --> 00:33:49.000
So this is in reference to onsite activities, and the substantive requirements, not administrative but substantive administrative would be considered any fees or the Permitting process which we talked about before so again, you have to adhere to the Substant portions, and these are 3

227
00:33:49.000 --> 00:34:07.000
different examples. So a substantive portion of a permit would be or any activity you need to have a quantitative health or risk-based restrictions based upon your exposure, to a hazard substance is you can use the Mcl's and Establish

228
00:34:07.000 --> 00:34:12.000
Drinking water standards, so one thing, an example of that is I had a site.

229
00:34:12.000 --> 00:34:31.000
Had the vapor intrusion, and we had to there were tenants inside the building, and so our risk Assessor had to Establish Site Specific numbers for that for the people, inside that building and I aired on the side of Caution and because I don't know Who's going I Don't know who They're going

230
00:34:31.000 --> 00:34:35.000
to employ. So I had it with sensitive with pregnant women and children.

231
00:34:35.000 --> 00:34:38.000
Because I didn't know who it's going to be on site.

232
00:34:38.000 --> 00:34:45.000
So that would be an example of your information of the Onsite Attendants, where it's cited location.

233
00:34:45.000 --> 00:34:51.000
It's this is near somewhat near to a water body. So those are all things, you're going to have to think about.

234
00:34:51.000 --> 00:35:10.000
And we identify a vapor, intrusion, risk which wasn't a risk until the tenth moved in until the Owner, a new owner bought the property, and then he moved Attendance in and Rented so that we had to Develop Site, specific Numbers and then there are Technology, based Requirements, such

235
00:35:10.000 --> 00:35:12.000
As a bit you might have to use a certain technology to clean up a hazardous substance.

236
00:35:12.000 --> 00:35:31.000
For instance, if you have an incinerator on site, sometimes you have to send it to an incinerator, so that would be something that you'd have to include and consider in some of your decisions, and that all comes down to understanding the alternatives that you're going to entertain, and then you

237
00:35:31.000 --> 00:35:36.000
know and Assess, those throughout the process, or maybe something that's a better way to

238
00:35:36.000 --> 00:35:50.000
To dispose of it instead of an incinerator, and so that might change, and then you'll include that in your rod, and then you have to consider all the the clean Air act Rick, read treatment and disposal you you may choose to treat it.

239
00:35:50.000 --> 00:35:52.000
Before you go off site, and then it'll be, you know.

240
00:35:52.000 --> 00:35:56.000
Then it won't be considered, it'll be considered clean.

241
00:35:56.000 --> 00:36:00.000
It'll be below Mcl's so there's a lot of different things.

242
00:36:00.000 --> 00:36:06.000
But your technology, based requirements. It'll all have to do with how you're going to handle things on site.

243
00:36:06.000 --> 00:36:21.000
And then there are restrictions upon certain Activities, and some special locations, for instance, again, we're hitting on flood planes, do you have any endangered species, do you have wetlands, because if you do then that's, going to be have you have to consider any kind of

244
00:36:21.000 --> 00:36:28.000
Permitting and make sure you adhere to the substantive portions of that

245
00:36:28.000 --> 00:36:35.000
And but again not the administrative. Okay, so the administrative requirements.

246
00:36:35.000 --> 00:36:52.000
Mechanisms, that facilitate, the implementation of the substantive requirements so that's how you're going to implement the subjugate portions of a requirement whether it be a permit or any other type of Requirement, some of the examples and you're Gonna have

247
00:36:52.000 --> 00:36:53.000
to seek approval from Ankle consultation with administrative bodies.

248
00:36:53.000 --> 00:37:01.000
They may be in the city, in the county, they may be another Federal agency, and then you're gonna have to figure out how to document, report an example.

249
00:37:01.000 --> 00:37:07.000
Is. If you have an on-site system, and you have to for instance, they don't.

250
00:37:07.000 --> 00:37:28.000
Wanna you don't want the tenant to have to pay for the electricity, that's being used by your thermal Treatment those are Hundreds and hundreds of dollars for thermal treatment, or if you have an spe system, those can mount up the cost so you'll have to drop an electrical poll and then you have to enter you have to

251
00:37:28.000 --> 00:37:32.000
Interface with the local city, county, about how to drop the electrical Poll.

252
00:37:32.000 --> 00:37:36.000
How you're going to get billed. So there's a whole lot of things, but that's just an example.

253
00:37:36.000 --> 00:37:40.000
Monitoring well, Abandonment is another great example.

254
00:37:40.000 --> 00:37:55.000
You have to go they have permits and many different States, but you don't have to get the permit, but you do have to find out the substantive portions, and make sure you abandon, that monitoring well, as for state standards,

255
00:37:55.000 --> 00:38:10.000
And then you prescribe methods and procedures and You're going to include those in some type of Decision document throughout your Remedial investigation about how you're going to Address these Issues and I'll sign, Up and Offsite Activities, must meet both now See the Permitting and all

256
00:38:10.000 --> 00:38:24.000
The things. These are onsite, circle, because, as per circle with statute there's. Some things we don't have to do, like get permits, and things like that but we still have to meet the substantive but not admin administrative, but as soon as you go to offsite

257
00:38:24.000 --> 00:38:26.000
Then you're gonna have to meet both substantive and administrative.

258
00:38:26.000 --> 00:38:41.000
You may have to get a permit to You know for treatment and disposal, or you know to take it off site, you've got to adhere to the offsite Rule and a lot, of different things, like that so keep that in mind and that's why, a lot, of people before they

259
00:38:41.000 --> 00:38:46.000
Transport, any kind of material offsite, a lot of times they'll treat it before they transport it.

260
00:38:46.000 --> 00:38:48.000
And then it also cuts down on your landfill.

261
00:38:48.000 --> 00:38:52.000
You know, costs like that so anyway, just a lot of things to consider.

262
00:38:52.000 --> 00:38:58.000
Throughout the Circle Process

263
00:38:58.000 --> 00:39:03.000
Alright, and so, when you consult with other agencies, that's always, you know, plan.

264
00:39:03.000 --> 00:39:18.000
Make sure that you're consulting with the right Agencies, and then all their sister agencies, that they interact with also the National, Historic Preservation, Act, you may encounter that and a lot, of sites as something you always have to check in when you when it's like it's

265
00:39:18.000 --> 00:39:33.000
listed, to the Mpl. They'll have they develop a list of trustees, and we tell them this, is now a super fun site in your area, and We're Going to interact with you consult if you have any concerns please Contact us but Throughout the Circle Process you should always be interacting with your

266
00:39:33.000 --> 00:39:36.000
agencies, and making sure that they their needs are met their concerns.

267
00:39:36.000 --> 00:39:41.000
Because there's different things. You can do to prevent or mitigate any impacts.

268
00:39:41.000 --> 00:40:00.000
So the national historic, Preservation Act, they're mainly about cultural resources, and sometimes tribes will have some cultural needs that you need to identify and work with them, to meet them the arrival, and historic preservation, act, is usually any kind of Federal projects in the area, and so you can interact

269
00:40:00.000 --> 00:40:08.000
with them and Figure out their limitations, their concerns, and end in endangered species act is a big one, and

270
00:40:08.000 --> 00:40:11.000
You always should see, if you have any endangered species and that's something.

271
00:40:11.000 --> 00:40:28.000
You'll work with your ecological risk assessor on and then the wild And Scenic Rivers Act, that's also you're gonna affect any Nearby, Water Bodies and they work with Doi and do a Department of Agriculture and Department, of Interior and the

272
00:40:28.000 --> 00:40:35.000
endangered species act, they also work with the national Marine fishery, Service, so their sister, organizations.

273
00:40:35.000 --> 00:40:41.000
You also have to inform and the fifth fish you wildlife, coordination act so they have a lot of sister agency.

274
00:40:41.000 --> 00:40:50.000
So you need to think about that when you're identifying any kind of these needs on your site, so there's a lot of considering that go into it and

275
00:40:50.000 --> 00:40:51.000
Yeah, so, make sure that you've interacted with your sister agencies.

276
00:40:51.000 --> 00:41:09.000
Any subgroups or Agencies and Tribes, and you, every region and EPA has a tribal expert, and if you have any the other day I had to Call my tribal Expert region, for to See if this Tribe even though They're 2 h from what Bus, Site, to See, if They'd Be interested

277
00:41:09.000 --> 00:41:11.000
In coordinating with me, and she said, just let them, know and then they'll let you know.

278
00:41:11.000 --> 00:41:21.000
So something to think about.

279
00:41:21.000 --> 00:41:22.000
Alright, so it looks like we have reached and apply your understanding opportunity.

280
00:41:22.000 --> 00:41:44.000
I will launch that a poll, question and ask which of the following Are substantive requirements, and you can select all that apply so you'll see 5 options up on the screen and there'll be a Box to the Left of each one you can select any or all is it a consultation with

281
00:41:44.000 --> 00:42:01.000
Administrative bodies, b technology-based requirements, c, restrictions, on activities in a flood, plane D record keeping processes, or e issuance of a permit, so I'll give you a moment to just review these checking off those boxes to the left of the answers that you

282
00:42:01.000 --> 00:42:02.000
Think, are substantive requirements, and then hit the submit button.

283
00:42:02.000 --> 00:42:09.000
When about a third of the audience have or we're.

284
00:42:09.000 --> 00:42:10.000
Now we're almost up to half of you, have sent your answers in.

285
00:42:10.000 --> 00:42:16.000
I do know that there are still lots of questions and comments.

286
00:42:16.000 --> 00:42:18.000
Coming in so I do appreciate everyone sending those in.

287
00:42:18.000 --> 00:42:23.000
We will pause in just a bit, but we want to encourage you to keep sharing your thoughts and specific situations and comments for your agency or in your area, because that will help.

288
00:42:23.000 --> 00:42:34.000
Improve Future deliveries to the course. So thank you. For all the Comments and feedback and questions keep those coming in Alright Demi.

289
00:42:34.000 --> 00:42:37.000
It looks like about two-thirds of the audience have answered this question.

290
00:42:37.000 --> 00:42:55.000
So I'm going to go ahead and close it down here in 3, 2, one, alright. And it looks like, most of the audience picked, b technology-based requirements and see restrictions on activities, in a flood, plane what is the right answer.

291
00:42:55.000 --> 00:43:17.000
B, and c are the answers we were looking for in this, quiz, remember consulting with an administrative body, if it's for administrative portions of a regulation that is not on site wouldn't have to be met record keeping processes are typically considered administrative and Permits.

292
00:43:17.000 --> 00:43:24.000
Are not required for onsite circa activities. So just something to keep in mind as always, you might have an example.

293
00:43:24.000 --> 00:43:30.000
Where that was considered an AR because of some sites.

294
00:43:30.000 --> 00:43:46.000
Specific Circumstance at your Site. But generally still, speaking those Types of Administrative Bodies, Record keeping, paper, work, administrative type Stuff does not have to be a met on Site for Circle Activities.

295
00:43:46.000 --> 00:43:47.000
All right. So now we're out, do you wanna pause for questions. Here, Dean.

296
00:43:47.000 --> 00:43:53.000
Okay, Alright demi, yeah. I I think we might have time.

297
00:43:53.000 --> 00:44:01.000
Okay.

298
00:44:01.000 --> 00:44:02.000
Okay.

299
00:44:02.000 --> 00:44:04.000
If it's okay, before we jump into the next segment, I think it might be a good time to stop and and take a look at some of the questions that are coming in so we have one.

300
00:44:04.000 --> 00:44:12.000
Quick question. Here are all state requirements. Tbcs, or are some errors.

301
00:44:12.000 --> 00:44:13.000
Some can be a they're not all automatically.

302
00:44:13.000 --> 00:44:31.000
Tbcs early in the slides, we talked about whether or not something is promulgated, if it's being, if it's more stringent than a Federal requirement, and if it's being applied consistently throughout the State, are the factors that would have to be considered to

303
00:44:31.000 --> 00:44:35.000
Determine, if that is going to be considered an error

304
00:44:35.000 --> 00:44:37.000
Okay. And could osha requirements be a Rars.

305
00:44:37.000 --> 00:44:47.000
So let's say we're talking about the protection of Worker health around when they're doing a remedial activity

306
00:44:47.000 --> 00:44:50.000
I I you know my first instinct With Osha requirements to say that typically wouldn't be considered an AR.

307
00:44:50.000 --> 00:45:00.000
But let me double check and I'll try and get up from our answer before the end of the Webinar

308
00:45:00.000 --> 00:45:02.000
Okay, alright, we do have an oh, sir.

309
00:45:02.000 --> 00:45:19.000
So a lot of times for the ocean that will be something that you document, Osha and your hasp your health and safety plan so that's how you handle that I haven't seen it documented, as they are but that doesn't mean it cannot be like Jimmy said but usually any Osha

310
00:45:19.000 --> 00:45:22.000
requirement or documenting, your health and safety plans

311
00:45:22.000 --> 00:45:23.000
Thank you, deja

312
00:45:23.000 --> 00:45:32.000
Okay, okay, we have a question here, about state policy. So I'm gonna there's 2 sort of themes.

313
00:45:32.000 --> 00:45:36.000
That I'm seeing pop up here one of the attendees just sort of generally asks.

314
00:45:36.000 --> 00:45:43.000
Can you define promulgated because they've worked in states where rules are written into state law, with baseline risk levels.

315
00:45:43.000 --> 00:45:54.000
And the ability to make them site. Specific so the program is implemented for all releases for the State, but they still call these tbc

316
00:45:54.000 --> 00:45:55.000
Interesting, I don't have the answer to that right. Off the top of my head, by promulgated.

317
00:45:55.000 --> 00:46:06.000
I believe that means that it's gone through the legislative process, in that state to be you know, officially approved.

318
00:46:06.000 --> 00:46:14.000
But I would need to double check as far as and then that from that definition we can double check why, it's still being considered as a Tbc.

319
00:46:14.000 --> 00:46:20.000
Perhaps it's less stringent than a Federal requirement, I'm not sure. But we can look into that

320
00:46:20.000 --> 00:46:21.000
Okay.

321
00:46:21.000 --> 00:46:34.000
So This is vidro when I worked at the Florida Department of Environmental Protection, they were developing it's called they call it Rebecca, but it's Risk-based Corrective Action and that has been Promulgated and So They had Lawyers Within the our

322
00:46:34.000 --> 00:46:54.000
Superfund division developing the guidance, and then they would go and speak with the governance bodies, the Committees and on Fdp of Florida, Congress and talk to them about what they were going to improve what they what they Felt, and So There was lots of back and forth but they

323
00:46:54.000 --> 00:46:55.000
Okay.

324
00:46:55.000 --> 00:47:03.000
Actually promulgated it through state, statute and it's actually a law within the state of Florida, and so then in Florida has so that's definitely propagated so one of the things that EPA will talk with Florida about is how well, have you consistently

325
00:47:03.000 --> 00:47:18.000
Applied this throughout your State for remedial Actions. And so that's the other part of that is has it been consistently applied, or have you cherry picked and used it here and there and not other places. So I don't know if that's, helpful but that's, been my experience

326
00:47:18.000 --> 00:47:31.000
Okay. and we did have a quick clarification regarding the Osha question for as an aer one of the Attendees, was able to chime in and simply say, that Osha is not an Aar or the Ncp.

327
00:47:31.000 --> 00:47:34.000
For worker, protection requirements. So it's not treated as an err.

328
00:47:34.000 --> 00:47:36.000
Although those protections are there. Okay, I want to go back here to this question about state, policy.

329
00:47:36.000 --> 00:47:47.000
So there's a question. If state policy is based on interpretation of state regulation.

330
00:47:47.000 --> 00:47:54.000
How would you handle that?

331
00:47:54.000 --> 00:48:12.000
If a State policy is based on an interpretation of a State regulation, I would say, look at the State Regulation, and can that be considered an aar don't go with the interpretation go with the actual reg itself and that should be easier to meet the criteria of what State regulations can

332
00:48:12.000 --> 00:48:16.000
Be considered as applicable or relevant and appropriate

333
00:48:16.000 --> 00:48:34.000
Okay, okay, and then just a quick term. Definition. Can you define what you're what you mean when you say onsite, is it just the property, or in some situations, could it include other elements or parts of the property within a defined groundwater management, zone

334
00:48:34.000 --> 00:48:50.000
So on. Site, we have a whole Webinar dedicated to this it was earlier in our series, but typically Onsite Activities, are anything that happened on the Npl Site, Groundwater, Plumes are considered part of the Site as Far as the Contamination Runs so even if a Line on A

335
00:48:50.000 --> 00:48:55.000
Map is so that's the Site Boundary but Groundwater has flowed off site.

336
00:48:55.000 --> 00:48:59.000
That is also considered part of the site. And when you add our Federal facility sites, they're very large.

337
00:48:59.000 --> 00:49:02.000
You, typically have dozens. Or more or use potentially, hundreds of way sites.

338
00:49:02.000 --> 00:49:14.000
So usually anything on that npl federal facility, Site, the national priorities. List,

339
00:49:14.000 --> 00:49:18.000
Is considered on site for the sake of that remedial action

340
00:49:18.000 --> 00:49:23.000
Okay, and then, I just want to get to one, other theme of questions here.

341
00:49:23.000 --> 00:49:39.000
And this is about substantive requirements one of the Attendees asked, did you say that those substantive requirements do apply at circlecytes, but that circlecytes do not have to Comply, with admirative requirements like permits for well construction

342
00:49:39.000 --> 00:49:41.000
That is correct. Yes, that is what we were stating

343
00:49:41.000 --> 00:49:59.000
Okay, so someone else then, said, Well, the comment about not having to get a permit seems misleading, for example, at a super fun site when I'm Doing Remedial Injections for institute groundwater remediation, a Uic or Underground injection control permit still needs to be

344
00:49:59.000 --> 00:50:02.000
Obtained right

345
00:50:02.000 --> 00:50:03.000
Okay.

346
00:50:03.000 --> 00:50:05.000
I don't believe you oh deidred, you have an example of this

347
00:50:05.000 --> 00:50:14.000
So what we've done, and you have you still have to consult with the agency, to let them know, and then they can choose to document it as they see.

348
00:50:14.000 --> 00:50:15.000
Fit so we consult with them, and make sure they they're meeting we're meeting the substant portions.

349
00:50:15.000 --> 00:50:22.000
If there's anything that's unclear, but you still need to I guess.

350
00:50:22.000 --> 00:50:38.000
Notification for lack of a better word. But you need to consult and let them, for instance, when I if I abandon a monitoring well, I always in Florida, you have to talk with water management, districts they're throughout the State, and we let them know that We're Abandoning we give them

351
00:50:38.000 --> 00:50:41.000
the, Information, and how we abandon it. But we don't.

352
00:50:41.000 --> 00:50:43.000
We don't apply for a permit. We don't pay fees.

353
00:50:43.000 --> 00:50:45.000
Is that clear it up

354
00:50:45.000 --> 00:50:53.000
Okay, okay, and, yeah, we, we did have someone, just comment that said, usually the uic permits are done through the State, at at their sites.

355
00:50:53.000 --> 00:50:54.000
Hmm! That's correct.

356
00:50:54.000 --> 00:50:59.000
Okay, and then, again, no permits are required for you, I see injections.

357
00:50:59.000 --> 00:51:07.000
But instead, you comply with the uic class 5 well requirements.

358
00:51:07.000 --> 00:51:08.000
That's great

359
00:51:08.000 --> 00:51:09.000
I identified as arors. That's how someone else has indicated you deal with this alright well, I know we we do.

360
00:51:09.000 --> 00:51:10.000
Have a packed agenda. But I appreciate that pause for Q.

361
00:51:10.000 --> 00:51:14.000
And a if we didn't get to your question. Please know, it's still in that Queue, Hopefully.

362
00:51:14.000 --> 00:51:23.000
We'll have time to come back to it. So keep those comments and Feedback and Interaction and question coming in for our instructors, and I will turn the Floor back to Emmy to carry on

363
00:51:23.000 --> 00:51:46.000
Yes, I'm very Excited for the next Portion of our Webinar, we will have a Case Study on Hanford, with some Representatives from the Washington, State Department of Ecology and the Department of Energy So I'll ask them, to join us, on video and I'll, Hand over the Mic to Teresa

364
00:51:46.000 --> 00:52:09.000
Hi, everyone, I'm Teresa Howell with the Washington, State Department of Ecology, one of the things that I do for Ecology is I work, closely with EPA and DOE, on Development of Avar's, for Hanford, Site Work and Provide some Expertise, on

365
00:52:09.000 --> 00:52:15.000
Good morning or good afternoon, everyone. I'm Jason Kapran, I work with the Department of Energy at the Hanford Site.

366
00:52:15.000 --> 00:52:27.000
My role is also working with circular decision-making, coordinating with folks like Teresa throughout our Circle of decision-making, Process, for soil, and groundwater I'm gonna Give you a little quick Overview, on What the Hanford Site Is for those who Don't

367
00:52:27.000 --> 00:52:33.000
Have familiarity with it. Handford sites about a 600 square mile site in Southeast Washington.

368
00:52:33.000 --> 00:52:50.000
This was a series of production reactors and Processing Facilities associated with nuclear weapons, production which is resulted in air multiple areas of significant soil, and groundwater contamination as I mentioned That's quite a It's a large site and it has already multiple Existing Plan Records of decision It's been

369
00:52:50.000 --> 00:52:57.000
Enough, a Circle decision Making Framework since 1989 and then There's Multiple Ongoing Efforts to get more records of decision.

370
00:52:57.000 --> 00:53:00.000
So I'll Kind of speak from that context, go ahead and flip to the next side slide for me.

371
00:53:00.000 --> 00:53:15.000
If you are demi, thank you so where it where it starts for Hanford from an errors perspective was with our Federal facility agreement, and consent. Order what we call the tri-party, agreement. This was a I mean I think we lost slides

372
00:53:15.000 --> 00:53:19.000
I am so sorry. Just 1 s that's my waiting photo.

373
00:53:19.000 --> 00:53:22.000
I apologize, okay.

374
00:53:22.000 --> 00:53:27.000
There, we go, okay.

375
00:53:27.000 --> 00:53:28.000
Go ahead. Jason, sorry

376
00:53:28.000 --> 00:53:34.000
No, not at all, so it it starts with our Federal facility agreement and consent order.

377
00:53:34.000 --> 00:53:48.000
Which we reached in 1989. This is an agreement between EPA DOE, and the Washington Department of Ecology, that's really important for us, from an errors, perspective because that's the the Launching point for a Lot of the Errors the Triparty Agreement Identified at a

378
00:53:48.000 --> 00:54:05.000
Very broad, general level, some of the top-level state, statutes and regulations that needed to be considered and reach an agreement between the 3 Parties, that Framework, provided the first step for the first record of Decision at the Hanford Site which were made in the 19 Nineties, mostly Interim Records of Decision but some final

379
00:54:05.000 --> 00:54:11.000
Records that at that point using what started in the Triparty Agreement.

380
00:54:11.000 --> 00:54:25.000
Those early rods built on that while considering the Decision-specific context for each one of those decisions and adding generally a greater level of Specificity, so taking that general identification that was in the Tri-party, Agreement, and then Adding on Details that were Appropriate, to

381
00:54:25.000 --> 00:54:29.000
The context of the decisions being made we've continued to build on that.

382
00:54:29.000 --> 00:54:34.000
You know Amy made a great point earlier the last thing you want to do is is grab a rod and just copy and Paste to be like oh, it.

383
00:54:34.000 --> 00:54:41.000
Was good. There let's just keep going with that. But nevertheless, as we continue to do record the decision for the Hanford Site.

384
00:54:41.000 --> 00:54:57.000
We do look at what Ars were identified for earlier decisions, either for an interim decision, at an area where we're making a non enron decision, or if there's a similar area next door in a similar media, and a Similar decision, we're looking at we always try and look back at what what that context, was that we're, not

385
00:54:57.000 --> 00:55:06.000
Reinventing the wheel, but we put a particular emphasis on looking at newer revised regulations to be sure that things that have changed especially since that decision.

386
00:55:06.000 --> 00:55:07.000
Was made or just it's kind of new on the horizon.

387
00:55:07.000 --> 00:55:22.000
That we're putting an emphasis on that and around how that factors into the errors, identification Process for a new record of decision, and then of course you also just have to consider those decision-specific factors, you know that specific technology, remedial option, that You're looking

388
00:55:22.000 --> 00:55:35.000
at in an area. Be sure you're, thinking of the Factors that work through that don't take for Granted. That it was adequately considered in a record a decision, you're looking at from 10 Years ago so Flip to the next one for me please send me

389
00:55:35.000 --> 00:55:51.000
So for us, errors, it canford errors, that identification starts early in the remedial action of evaluation, selection Process, and Emmy has alluded to this is just a good good way to go about it and we do document, it throughout that circular process typically the discussions really start very early

390
00:55:51.000 --> 00:56:08.000
on but the first where we see Document, implementation of it is in our Remedial Investigation and Feasibility Study, work, plan we seek to make a early identification of what the Likely Errors, are as Amy said There's, you can't lock down an Err at that Point, but It's, a good stage to be

391
00:56:08.000 --> 00:56:22.000
sure that you're looking at those general initial ones that will have key key impacts, that you're factoring, that in and thinking of it, you can then use that issue go through your remedial investigation and Feasibility, Study, process that by the time, you're getting to a Feasibility, study, you can have a greatly.

392
00:56:22.000 --> 00:56:35.000
refined list. That's based to the technologies and remedial Alternatives, that you're considering, and then of course, the Rubber finally hits the Road in the record of Decision and Throughout this Process and our Experience, At Hand for You're Focusing Down the Level of Detail obviously Based on Remedial

393
00:56:35.000 --> 00:56:38.000
Alternatives that Don't get Selected some errors may be deleted.

394
00:56:38.000 --> 00:56:54.000
They don't have an application or the specific details of the application of given a or may get more clarity, as you hone in on that final alternative, you're selecting there's discussion Touch Points throughout that process for Us, they occurs, part of routine Project Interactions Teresa, and I

395
00:56:54.000 --> 00:57:07.000
Talk with each other, and others at ebay and Ecology on a fairly regular basis, just let me try to know what's going on keeping in on things, and then there's also Formal Document, Review Processes as I mentioned you see it that we included in our Rfs, work Plans and our

396
00:57:07.000 --> 00:57:11.000
Fs. Which go to review by Ep and ecology.

397
00:57:11.000 --> 00:57:14.000
So it gives them a chance to be sure that we're really all on the same page from a few levels.

398
00:57:14.000 --> 00:57:30.000
Think, Thanks to the framework of those earlier key decisions and those kind of routine interactions we have that the process usually proceeds fairly smoothly, but the challenges do sometimes Arise in decision-specific contexts, so some challenges, you could run into or that we run into certainly is is

399
00:57:30.000 --> 00:57:33.000
Kind of Consistency and durability, across multiple remediation projects.

400
00:57:33.000 --> 00:57:48.000
As I said, we've been making decisions at Hanford since 1,900 ninetys, and sometimes applying the intent of earlier interpretations, or agreements and Consideration of changes to regulations can prompt Discussions, about what Elements of Errors, are Applicable so be sensitive to that you

401
00:57:48.000 --> 00:58:06.000
Know we always try to have an awareness of where agreement have been made and honoring those but recognizing where context may have changed a little bit thanks to changes in regulations or specific application also level of detail is sometimes a challenge we've encountered we the the tendency early on in

402
00:58:06.000 --> 00:58:20.000
Rods was to identify errors very very broadly, whereas we've gone more and more, to trying to focus in on really the specific parts that are trying to be a Rs, that's double-ch because it takes more time to get consensus on the specificity, but in my opinion, it

403
00:58:20.000 --> 00:58:33.000
Pays dividends on the back end, because you're figuring out you're getting good firm agreement on what it is that's really your error element rather than a broad identification that really just leaves the interpretation, to the remedial implementation, phase you're just setting up a problem for

404
00:58:33.000 --> 00:58:47.000
That stage, so Teresa and I spend a lot of time together working through those kind of pieces for what we need to identify and the last challenge piece that that we run into a lot, is is when you get into elements that are incorporated in regulations by reference particularly when you have State.

405
00:58:47.000 --> 00:58:51.000
Regulations that interact with Federal regulations and that's.

406
00:58:51.000 --> 00:59:05.000
Sometimes it's kind of like this regulation points to this regulation which points here, how much documentation do you need to get into that's that's a case specific discussion to be sure you capture all the elements our preference, that we found works well, is is to go.

407
00:59:05.000 --> 00:59:07.000
With go with simplicity, such as you can follow the thread.

408
00:59:07.000 --> 00:59:08.000
But it is something that you just have to take the time to work through Teresa.

409
00:59:08.000 --> 00:59:11.000
Ars to the various projects in our nuclear waste program

410
00:59:11.000 --> 00:59:12.000
I should hand over you. There. See if there's other challenges, or anything you want to speak

411
00:59:12.000 --> 00:59:13.000
I think he covered it, Jason, it's really just a matter of timing and kind of Weighing, the Risks and Benefits of really drilling down into the Details early on

412
00:59:13.000 --> 00:59:14.000
Okay, and I think we're ready to go to the next slide.

413
00:59:14.000 --> 00:59:15.000
Then Lessons, Learned, So thank you, Jason, the the thing that we've really found is Jason was mentioning.

414
00:59:15.000 --> 00:59:16.000
That is key is early communication. it's important to involve subject matter Experts in those early stages of Identifying Ars, and for example, working with the State Oftentimes that Includes other Agencies, so the Department of Health for Example will, get involved in Identifying Air

415
00:59:16.000 --> 00:59:17.000
Arars even though ecology might be the Lead Regulator on each, as Jason mentioned that early stage is typically the Rfs work.

416
00:59:17.000 --> 00:59:18.000
Plan, so you really want to be having those conversations early on in the process, we want to AIM, for no surprises.

417
00:59:18.000 --> 00:59:19.000
Once a rod is drafted. There are instances where public comment on a proposed plan might raise issues even legal issues that weren't pondered in the earlier Stages but the more you've had those Conversations Upfront the easier It's gonna be to Work through those Challenges

418
00:59:19.000 --> 00:59:20.000
At Hanford, Apa, and the State of Washington have an mou, that a memorandum of understanding, that provides some framework for AR, Identification, and Consistency and We've tried to stay pretty close to that over the years most of the Disagreements Arise from Elements that

419
00:59:20.000 --> 00:59:21.000
Are incorporated into the regulations by reference, as as Jason was mentioning as a Rod is developed the list of Potential Errors that you encounter is likely to Shrink over time.

420
00:59:21.000 --> 00:59:22.000
However that specificity within the Given Regulation might be increased as a remedy as proposed.

421
00:59:22.000 --> 00:59:23.000
Refined, you work through some of those details again, potential errors that are specific to a remedy, or a technology that isn't selected will often get deleted at the rod stage and often what i've observed is that the broadly, identified arors, Tend to get more

422
00:59:23.000 --> 00:59:53.000
Specificity, including identification of those specific elements. Jason, or I mean, did you have anything to add on that slide

423
01:01:45.000 --> 01:01:48.000
No, not for me, Teresa

424
01:01:48.000 --> 01:01:53.000
I guess I'll just take a second to say when I was over media project manager at Hanford.

425
01:01:53.000 --> 01:02:11.000
I had, the I worked with Jason and Teresa, and They're really great, the nature of your relationships, with your counterparts, at the Federal and State agencies is so important so you can talk about these things, without it Blowing up suddenly in a meeting or you know having that

426
01:02:11.000 --> 01:02:12.000
Email, traffic, of disgruntled people, going back and forth.

427
01:02:12.000 --> 01:02:31.000
So I just want to give them props, for being really good partners in the Cleanup efforts at Hanford and I would invite anyone from our Webinar, if you have a question for Teresa or Jason, please type it into the Q&A but I'll start with a Question

428
01:02:31.000 --> 01:02:47.000
I have for for each of you, through this process, eventually lawyers are gonna get involved, can you talk about what point in the process your agency typically starts coordinating with legal for a Rars

429
01:02:47.000 --> 01:03:14.000
Sure so I can kick that one off. We typically do not get legal involvement.

430
01:03:14.000 --> 01:03:19.000
And for us, I mean councils. You know down the down the hall, from me.

431
01:03:19.000 --> 01:03:22.000
Basically, so we typically give ours the heads up that we're in.

432
01:03:22.000 --> 01:03:25.000
You know that we're at that stage. Let them know what's going on gauge, the Interest?

433
01:03:25.000 --> 01:03:30.000
But really, yeah, that the earnest engagement for us happens as we're approaching the Rot phase.

434
01:03:30.000 --> 01:03:31.000
But there's there's awareness and preparedness before that.

435
01:03:31.000 --> 01:03:32.000
Everyone says it's beautiful Emmy just let you know

436
01:03:32.000 --> 01:03:38.000
But where we get into legal reviews is really as we approach the right phase

437
01:03:38.000 --> 01:03:48.000
That sounds, about right, for EPA. As well, having that early communication with your legal counsel regardless of what agency you're with is important.

438
01:03:48.000 --> 01:04:00.000
I can say things, get a little contentious, or maybe the pressure rises just a little bit.

439
01:04:00.000 --> 01:04:01.000
Okay.

440
01:04:01.000 --> 01:04:02.000
When we start getting Project Managers, Attorneys Management in the Room, but the Better, the Earlier and more Freely, you Communicate the better, I, think the process will be Do Do we have Any Questions from others

441
01:04:02.000 --> 01:04:03.000
Yeah, we did have a question that came in regarding one of the bullets.

442
01:04:03.000 --> 01:04:30.000
Here on the Slide. So Regarding that statement that Potential Errors not associated with the Selected Remedy Or Eliminated, why wouldn't all errors Relevant to All of the Remedies that were considered remain Relevant

443
01:04:30.000 --> 01:04:33.000
Teresa Jason, did you wanna give your thoughts

444
01:04:33.000 --> 01:04:50.000
I I can feel that so, for example, if you had an aer that was related to in to subsurface injection for a particular tech for a particular remedial alternative, and you chose a remedial alternative, that had nothing to do with subsurface injection that your element wouldn't have

445
01:04:50.000 --> 01:04:51.000
applicability anymore. So you wouldn't continue it in the rod, those are the kind of cases.

446
01:04:51.000 --> 01:04:55.000
Where there's a deletion of it.

447
01:04:55.000 --> 01:05:20.000
Another thing is through out this process. I think that the more communication you have about it is really really really important to have with all all people's and on one thing like we were talking, about consulting about u ucs, we actually proposed underground, injections, or do we did

448
01:05:20.000 --> 01:05:21.000
Hmm.

449
01:05:21.000 --> 01:05:35.000
for Samantha River, Site, and after we sat down with the State and all the Counter, the Uic Section, They're, not Part of the Super Fun, Branch, but so we sat Down, with them we found another Alternative, because the State, had really strong Reservations, about it and It, Wasn't about

450
01:05:35.000 --> 01:05:38.000
Permitting, but it's about the substantive portions of the permit.

451
01:05:38.000 --> 01:05:49.000
And so I believe we found another avenue and But that was through consultation, and it took many meetings, but it all worked out, and that's why I think communication is so important

452
01:05:49.000 --> 01:05:50.000
Well, right in line with that we have a couple of comments and questions that came in.

453
01:05:50.000 --> 01:06:20.000
So let me just read through these ones, a number of people are chiming in that they do recommend coordinating ars with other agencies before you meet with the facility and include your legal Counsel, as part of that because if you can walk in with a united voice it's.

454
01:06:22.000 --> 01:06:23.000
Hmm.

455
01:06:23.000 --> 01:06:26.000
Just overall going to reduce time to negotiate especially if EPA, is already on board with the State arars, others are again chiming in that their agency works with lawyers, who help put their Ars together at the Fs Stage and that gets to one of my questions Someone else

456
01:06:26.000 --> 01:06:41.000
Asked I thought a Rars accepted during the Feasibility or Fs, Stage are accepted, during the Fs as that evaluates, the Remedial Actions and then it's the Rod that Identifies, the Remedy

457
01:06:41.000 --> 01:06:58.000
Notice, though in your rod, a very important section is your ars table, which identifies specifically what requirements have to be met and that's going to help ensure that the remedy Is protective of human Health in the environment so you would only focus on the selected remedy

458
01:06:58.000 --> 01:07:05.000
And for those, the ars in those tables as just mentioned. If it's not pertinent, you wouldn't include it

459
01:07:05.000 --> 01:07:17.000
And and Amy may be to supplement that to that if there had been a significant change in aros through your Fs, and proposed plan process that really should be documented in your rod, that that change occurred across that too.

460
01:07:17.000 --> 01:07:18.000
Alright.

461
01:07:18.000 --> 01:07:22.000
Right like I think Theresa use the language. If it wasn't previously anticipated.

462
01:07:22.000 --> 01:07:28.000
Then that is something that merits a discussion in the record of decision

463
01:07:28.000 --> 01:07:47.000
Okay. Alright, and then just a quick clarification, that the Ncp requires a Rars in the Fs for Alternatives, and the Rod, must include a Rars for the Selected Remedy, own so thank you for that Ncp reference we always Appreciate the Regulatory, Framework

464
01:07:47.000 --> 01:07:53.000
As well, okay, so I think, just in the interest of time Emmy we might be time to move on to the next segment.

465
01:07:53.000 --> 01:07:58.000
I think we're just a few minutes behind, but we can make that up. So I want to turn the floor back to you.

466
01:07:58.000 --> 01:07:59.000
Sure and just another big thank you to Jason and Teresa for joining us today.

467
01:07:59.000 --> 01:08:09.000
We appreciate your input and I will now hand it over to Ditra, to talk about documenting, arors

468
01:08:09.000 --> 01:08:14.000
Alright, so wrap this up with our previous conversations.

469
01:08:14.000 --> 01:08:22.000
We're gonna talk about how you, document the arrows once you go going forward, in the process.

470
01:08:22.000 --> 01:08:41.000
So the rod as we talked about to document. Arors, as follows, so and I also wanna preface this with EPA has a Structured Rod document, about how you structure your record of decision however, when You Work with the Federal Facility they Don't have to follow EPA structures.

471
01:08:41.000 --> 01:08:45.000
for documents, they a lot of times. They have their own structures and

472
01:08:45.000 --> 01:08:52.000
So what you do is, if it's not in for instance, if your major are our hey Rars.

473
01:08:52.000 --> 01:09:03.000
Exc excuse me so, if your Major ars are not discussed in a section called Description of Alternatives, you can make sure that your major are Ars are Captured elsewhere.

474
01:09:03.000 --> 01:09:11.000
So my point is is you know we're with your federal facility, and if they you know, they have sometimes structure is less important than content.

475
01:09:11.000 --> 01:09:29.000
So make sure you check all the boxes and and that you've got the appropriate information in your rod, but so Major a a r should be captured in the appropriate Section the EPA is description, of Alternatives, and most People Use that I believe and AR Compliance should be summarized

476
01:09:29.000 --> 01:09:35.000
in summary of comparative analysis and That's a lot of times to the comparative analysis.

477
01:09:35.000 --> 01:09:39.000
You'll have in the rod, and then, as we've mentioned some of your ars may fall out.

478
01:09:39.000 --> 01:09:44.000
When you have the chosen alternative, and some people handle that differently most of the time.

479
01:09:44.000 --> 01:10:02.000
People talk about why these arrows that were chosen are need to be applicable to this site need to be used for the site and for the definite for the different Requirements but definitely all the arors, that were for the selected remedy, should be Listed and briefly.

480
01:10:02.000 --> 01:10:08.000
described and the Statutory Determinations section And so most people and almost all the Rods.

481
01:10:08.000 --> 01:10:13.000
I've seen they have tables for the aros and explanations, and then they'll have some discussion.

482
01:10:13.000 --> 01:10:37.000
After our before the AR Tables, but the AR Tables make it easy for reference, and almost everyone has tables, but let's see I think it did I miss anything I don't think so oh, you need to the record of decision, should also include an explanation.

483
01:10:37.000 --> 01:10:44.000
Or the or a basis for any kind of aar waiver, and you need to have you have Tbcs.

484
01:10:44.000 --> 01:10:59.000
You need to have a discussion of the Tbcs and how they support your the ars that were chosen and just and make sure you explained and It's Understood, how the Tbcs were Identified and how They're Going to be Used and definitely you should have

485
01:10:59.000 --> 01:11:15.000
This conversation throughout the Circle process, and you want to consider errors in your Ri, in the Fs, also the pros plan in the Rod will be Summary Part of the remedial action and they should comply with the major Arors and describe why the report why the requirement is either

486
01:11:15.000 --> 01:11:36.000
Applicable or Relevant and Appropriate, so that should be in in your Description, and the Attorneys, a Lot of times, will most of the Time they will address that whether it's applicable or Relevant, and Appropriate, and how it Applies, to your specific side Actions.

487
01:11:36.000 --> 01:11:55.000
Alright and Removal Actions, Removal Actions, those are they can be time, critical or non-time critical time, critical 6 months, non, time critical, is 6 months, or more and so the removal actions, must also comply, with your aros to the extent practicable alright and

488
01:11:55.000 --> 01:12:01.000
That means that, and you can't for an instance, if you have an emergency, removal.

489
01:12:01.000 --> 01:12:06.000
That's gonna be different. That's gonna have different ars than time critical or non time critical.

490
01:12:06.000 --> 01:12:22.000
Because if you have, you know an explosion or something, that's an explosive capacity, or you have dream drums that are leaking or anything like that then you're gonna have different arors, so if you have the linking drums, and you caught it then you know maybe you only have to look

491
01:12:22.000 --> 01:12:26.000
At the soil, and it didn't get into the groundwater, so what they would do.

492
01:12:26.000 --> 01:12:37.000
Is just look at the soil errors and so a lot of times they'll just do a removal app do they get the Leaking Drones, taken care of which would be an emergency response and then that could go into a time critical if it was a large amount of drums if

493
01:12:37.000 --> 01:12:39.000
It's just a few drums. They'll just do it at the same time.

494
01:12:39.000 --> 01:12:44.000
Is there an emergency response, there's a large number of drums.

495
01:12:44.000 --> 01:12:53.000
Sometimes it can be over acres, or you know in a whole building, so then you have to assess, and you have to look at you know has it has it interface with groundwater, did it even make it.

496
01:12:53.000 --> 01:13:10.000
To the water table. If not then you, just have to worry about soul, ars and the remote for the Removal Action, so the things that Determine, the Compliance with arors as we Mentioned is is It Practicable the Urgency of the Situation which would be An Emergency Emergency

497
01:13:10.000 --> 01:13:14.000
Action and then the Scope of the Removal Action, which I talked about.

498
01:13:14.000 --> 01:13:19.000
You know acres, a building, or just a few drums on site.

499
01:13:19.000 --> 01:13:24.000
And so that will dictate how you apply and use your arors.

500
01:13:24.000 --> 01:13:34.000
Just to jump in on that dread the box. We have up here about definitions of these words, because we ask well, what is practical plumbing.

501
01:13:34.000 --> 01:13:42.000
And that can be a discussion, EPA, state, regulators, and the lead Federal agency will talk about at link.

502
01:13:42.000 --> 01:13:59.000
So these definitely, just kind of help give you an idea practicable does imply that you're looking at the Current Conditions like deedra said, the urgency of the Situation and the Scope of the Removal Action while Something, That's, Possible I Mean It's like Possible in the Realm of all

503
01:13:59.000 --> 01:14:04.000
Possibilities, so that's a much broader term, and then feasible being what's actually going to get you to your desired result.

504
01:14:04.000 --> 01:14:13.000
So those are not in the Ncp it's just to give you a better understanding of how each of those terms can be viewed.

505
01:14:13.000 --> 01:14:23.000
But definitely talk about that right? Because my idea, practicable as an EPA, regulator, might not be other people's idea practicable

506
01:14:23.000 --> 01:14:35.000
Yeah, that's absolutely true. For instance, if you have something that's gonna release to a surface water, then that's of importance, and you would use different Ars for the Surface, water, because you'd have to see where it's going to be exposed where it may enter that surface, Butter, and

507
01:14:35.000 --> 01:14:49.000
If the emergency react and if it's an emergency action, they're a lot of times, they will build a berm, or they will make it so it doesn't some type of Barrier and There's lots of Different, Barriers, so you it does it never makes it.

508
01:14:49.000 --> 01:14:52.000
To that exposure. Point. So there's lots of different things, but then you'd have to deal with soil.

509
01:14:52.000 --> 01:15:07.000
If it makes it to the surface, water, then you have to deal with surface water, if it makes it to the Groundwater table, then you'll have to look at Soil and Groundwater, so

510
01:15:07.000 --> 01:15:23.000
Right, so developing Protective remedies, so the circle of 121 requires a selection of remedial actions to be protective, of human health and the environment, and to remain Protective of human Health in the Environment EPA's approach to determining protectiveness we do a risk

511
01:15:23.000 --> 01:15:41.000
Assessment, and again, that's you develop your site specific contaminant levels, your contaminations on Site, you see, are there any sensitive groups, children, pregnant women are their Exposure, Timeframes for instance, Tc could be a Driver and

512
01:15:41.000 --> 01:15:42.000
Vapor, Intrusion, because it has a really short exposure. Time.

513
01:15:42.000 --> 01:15:59.000
I think it's like days 30 days, or something like that and expose your timeframes, on a soccer field, Versus so you're also gonna consider your Reuse scenario, is it going to be a soccer field where you just have People Exposed for a couple Hours

514
01:15:59.000 --> 01:16:04.000
at the soccer game, or is it going to be inside a home is a paper intrusion in a home?

515
01:16:04.000 --> 01:16:07.000
So those are completely different. Scenarios, and that's where your risk assessor comes in.

516
01:16:07.000 --> 01:16:24.000
And they they develop, a site, specific levels, as necessary or they'll determine the use 10 to the minus 4, do you use 10 to the minus 6, if it's an industrial, you know business, industrial that's, usually 10 and minus, 4 unless there's.

517
01:16:24.000 --> 01:16:42.000
Some reason for it to be lower, and if it's a residential, then it's 10 to the minus 6, and if There's any special Considerations, we may even look at at Site, specifically lowering it even more so but whatever you determine, your it your errors, and your risk, Assessment.

518
01:16:42.000 --> 01:16:47.000
Tbcs must be attained by the remedial action, and they must be protective of human health.

519
01:16:47.000 --> 01:16:50.000
In the environment.

520
01:16:50.000 --> 01:16:57.000
And then also have to consider any Multiple Pathways, and then any kind of Synergistic effects.

521
01:16:57.000 --> 01:17:13.000
If you have multiple contaminants, that's another thing, that your risk assessor, looks at and if you that are synergy, and there's interactions multiple from multiple contaminants and then also look at that you may even have an error that's lower still

522
01:17:13.000 --> 01:17:33.000
Alright, when, and where aro should be attained EPA's policy is to attain a roars and Tbcs, if if they're important necessary for your Site and they Pertain To either Contaminant Levels or the Performance and Design Standards and this is Very Important All Points

523
01:17:33.000 --> 01:17:41.000
Of Potential exposure. That's a very key concept so if it's surface water, as I mentioned it wherever it's going to enter the surface.

524
01:17:41.000 --> 01:17:56.000
Water that's a potential exposure route. You need to consider that same with any kind of did you, a newly identified Vapor Intrusion route or an identified paper, intrusion route so those are some of the things you're gonna have to consider for a wars and tbc's as

525
01:17:56.000 --> 01:18:13.000
as applicable. you have to develop a reasonable, a reasonable maximum exposure scenario, and then you determine your cleanup, goals and ensure, protectiveness, so so do you have a paper, intrusion, problem if you do then you're gonna have to speak

526
01:18:13.000 --> 01:18:30.000
with your attorneys, and see about a indoor air Exposure Numbers and Surface Water, Exposure Numbers, if It's, the Surface, Water, Grammar, It's, Brown Water and at Each Potential Point of Exposure, you have to Figure that Out, and Figure, Out, your Maximum

527
01:18:30.000 --> 01:18:33.000
exposure, scenario.

528
01:18:33.000 --> 01:18:52.000
Alright, exposure Point, Consideration Groundwater has to be Throughout the Contaminated Plume, That's Key and If Stata be on the Edge of A Waste Management, Area when Less when was left in place so the Key is there Throughout the Container Bloom and That's again, with the Site.

529
01:18:52.000 --> 01:18:57.000
Definition. Your circle site is defined by your the left, where your contamination is cited.

530
01:18:57.000 --> 01:19:01.000
Then Matter, about property, boundaries, your Circle site is determined by contamination.

531
01:19:01.000 --> 01:19:05.000
So groundwater. It's throughout the whole plume surface.

532
01:19:05.000 --> 01:19:10.000
Waters At Selected Levels, be attained at a Pointer points where the release enters a surface water.

533
01:19:10.000 --> 01:19:30.000
So again, if you have contamination that's entering a surface water, that is the area that you're that you identify and you delineate, and that's where you have whatever Tests, that are necessary sampling and to determine, levels and air is the same way, you might think about

534
01:19:30.000 --> 01:19:42.000
Air, direction. When you're doing this. And so you're going to think about if it's in an industrial area, then you're going to have to in the negative, 4 if it's in a you've got a Housing Development just up the Street then That's a whole different

535
01:19:42.000 --> 01:19:52.000
Exposure scenario. So your main key is you determine your Maximum Exposure Scenario at each potential exposure Point

536
01:19:52.000 --> 01:20:05.000
And you also don't forget about sensitive populations, which children, you know, if you've got a neighborhood, nearby, children, pregnant women, and all things like that day, care

537
01:20:05.000 --> 01:20:23.000
Thank you, deidra, for talking about, exposure point concentrations, those types of conversations come up a lot when you're developing your errors, so something to keep in mind, we're gonna jump into abras, identification, and analysis, we're looking at the actual ways.

538
01:20:23.000 --> 01:20:26.000
You can determine is it applicable or is it relevant and appropriate.

539
01:20:26.000 --> 01:20:28.000
So let's look through these questions together, so if you're pretty need to a rise or like where do.

540
01:20:28.000 --> 01:20:37.000
I even start with this, so some questions you can ask yourself to help identify A.

541
01:20:37.000 --> 01:20:46.000
Bars are things. Like, alright. Well, this remedy restore groundwater, or is it looking at contaminated soils if that's the case.

542
01:20:46.000 --> 01:20:51.000
Perhaps you have to consider safe tricky Water Act, primary Drinking Water standards ups.

543
01:20:51.000 --> 01:20:52.000
If you're dealing with Groundwater. These are just.

544
01:20:52.000 --> 01:20:56.000
These are not the end, all this's just a starting point.

545
01:20:56.000 --> 01:21:02.000
Questions, you could ask yourself if you're dealing with institute exit, true treatment systems, do.

546
01:21:02.000 --> 01:21:12.000
You have to look at air missions under recra, those may apply, are you discharging to surface water, or is there emission into air, from a treatment system you might need to look at the clean.

547
01:21:12.000 --> 01:21:20.000
Water, act, Npds Permit Substantive Requirements, or the Clean Air Act to consider what has to be done?

548
01:21:20.000 --> 01:21:29.000
Or do you have a site that's located within a flood, plain, wetland, or other critical habitat.

549
01:21:29.000 --> 01:21:41.000
If so now you'd likely need to take closer look at Nepa and also Section 404 of the Clean Water Act, a Couple of other Questions, you might find here helpful to ask yourself.

550
01:21:41.000 --> 01:21:53.000
Are things like, well does this generate waste like material that has to be disposed of, for example, is being removed from an area, of contamination or is it still being actively managed.

551
01:21:53.000 --> 01:21:57.000
Are you leaving waste in place at a landfill.

552
01:21:57.000 --> 01:22:01.000
What about the remediation waste that you're working with what type?

553
01:22:01.000 --> 01:22:06.000
Is it does it have? Pcbs. Does it have rad radiological contamination.

554
01:22:06.000 --> 01:22:22.000
Excuse me, or is there any secondary Waste after treatment that leaves you with residuals that have to be dealt with as well or just how are you managing that waste that's a big question anytime you hear Waste, your likely going to be looking at the record hazardous?

555
01:22:22.000 --> 01:22:27.000
And solid waste amendments for a wars that I'll apply, and record generally is one of the Regs.

556
01:22:27.000 --> 01:22:35.000
That provides the most arars in our records of decisions, not always, but typically that's.

557
01:22:35.000 --> 01:22:37.000
What we've seen

558
01:22:37.000 --> 01:22:41.000
Talking about coordination and consultation, with other Federal and State programs, we've alluded to this, a number of times.

559
01:22:41.000 --> 01:22:47.000
So when we're looking at sources of potential errors.

560
01:22:47.000 --> 01:22:52.000
We've talked about other, federal environmental laws that are administered by EPA.

561
01:22:52.000 --> 01:22:53.000
Those might have to be considered. The if you have a state that's authorized to implement its retro program.

562
01:22:53.000 --> 01:23:06.000
Those laws, any Federal agency, administrative laws. There's a lot that can be considered also cases.

563
01:23:06.000 --> 01:23:13.000
When you have more stringent environmental laws in a system for sighting, then you do at the Federal level.

564
01:23:13.000 --> 01:23:31.000
And again, this is all to ensure that your remedies comply with the substantive acts, aspects of the errors that are identified, and any other Federal State program offices that need to be consulted should be included in this Process because they're going to be able to help you ensure, that you

565
01:23:31.000 --> 01:23:52.000
Are in fact, in compliance with these ars so with chemical, specific arars, if you are looking at that for example, the Safe Drinking Water, act Mcl's Mclgs the goals that are set above 0 or clean Water Act, Water, quality, criteria, your Wqcs

566
01:23:52.000 --> 01:24:08.000
For surface water. You're dealing with those ars again that are health or risk-based, and it's you're looking at what's going to potentially be discharged to the environment, or remain in the environment, with action, specific Avar specifically, you might be looking at record

567
01:24:08.000 --> 01:24:09.000
Closure requirements for subtitle C, and D landfills.

568
01:24:09.000 --> 01:24:15.000
We've mentioned the Mpds requirements for point Source.

569
01:24:15.000 --> 01:24:31.000
Discharges, a number of times, or the Clean Airact Knee Shaps For Hazardous Air Pollutants, Asbestos and Radio New Clients, so Anytime You're Dealing with These Types of Actions, Airstripping, Cappy Dredging, Excavation, That's, Going

570
01:24:31.000 --> 01:24:38.000
To open up, or you know have a number of a bars that are going to apply with location, specific ars we've mentioned things like the clean Water act, the record location requirements.

571
01:24:38.000 --> 01:25:02.000
Meet the national historic preservation, act inangered species act all we're just hitting on these again, because these are the a Rars we see, very frequently used in records of decisions, so being familiar with these is it really important going to be really helpful I'm just looking quickly at

572
01:25:02.000 --> 01:25:14.000
my notes. Okay, next, we have a quiz to help apply your understanding with a graphic to go along with the Questions.

573
01:25:14.000 --> 01:25:18.000
So, Jean, can you take us through these

574
01:25:18.000 --> 01:25:23.000
I absolutely can so I'm about to pop that poll question up.

575
01:25:23.000 --> 01:25:30.000
And I'm going to launch it. Now this is a select all that apply style. Question.

576
01:25:30.000 --> 01:25:35.000
So in this particular Scenario, we're going to ask you in looking at it.

577
01:25:35.000 --> 01:25:41.000
Where would action specific arars apply in this Pump and Treat situation.

578
01:25:41.000 --> 01:25:44.000
So we have a well screen with if you look in the lower left of the diagram, which is option A.

579
01:25:44.000 --> 01:25:57.000
You have option. B. Which is above the ground surface, and that holding tank where you're extracted contaminated water is coming out and going.

580
01:25:57.000 --> 01:26:15.000
Into you have moving to the right and the lower portion of the dial of the diagram options, C which is one of the reinforcing wells, where the treated water has been pushed back into the groundwater Zone then going Back up top We have Option D which is Part of

581
01:26:15.000 --> 01:26:30.000
The treatment train components where we have air strippers and granular activated carbon or Dac, and that treatment treated water is passing or coming out from that treatment train, component, and then we also have options, e and I don't know why there's an Option, f because I

582
01:26:30.000 --> 01:26:33.000
Don't See, the option of on the Slide. It may have been a mistake on mine.

583
01:26:33.000 --> 01:26:35.000
A trick question. There's no app

584
01:26:35.000 --> 01:26:39.000
I I got very excited when frozen these in I apologize, disregard F.

585
01:26:39.000 --> 01:26:40.000
No great.

586
01:26:40.000 --> 01:26:45.000
But he is the last one, which is that area where we're discharging to surface water so we're going to point out on the Diagram of those 5 A. B, C.

587
01:26:45.000 --> 01:26:55.000
D. E where would action specific arars apply in the Pumper trade scenario.

588
01:26:55.000 --> 01:27:00.000
I looks like about a third of you have set your responses in.

589
01:27:00.000 --> 01:27:04.000
These are pick all that apply. So you can check off the boxes to the left and then hit, the submits.

590
01:27:04.000 --> 01:27:06.000
If you've already submitted your answers and F was included Don't Worry, we Won't hold that against you at all.

591
01:27:06.000 --> 01:27:21.000
But I apologize for that oversight. But you can continue to share your answers with about half of you having sent them on in I'm going to go Ahead and close the Pull Down here.

592
01:27:21.000 --> 01:27:28.000
In 3, 2, one, and let's talk about your responses.

593
01:27:28.000 --> 01:27:29.000
So it looks like by far, about 80% of the audience, or so picked, C.

594
01:27:29.000 --> 01:27:42.000
D, and E, so those items on the right side of the Diagram, your Treatment Training components, your Reinjection.

595
01:27:42.000 --> 01:27:47.000
Well, and then the discharge to surface waters. I mean, what were the answers you really

596
01:27:47.000 --> 01:27:51.000
So the answers we were looking for were C. D. And E.

597
01:27:51.000 --> 01:28:14.000
So looks like the majority of our participants, nailed it with that with a here, we've just have contamination in a groundwater plume, that we in this example, we weren't considering that something action specific and with B, water and a holding tank it, might have various contaminants, in it but

598
01:28:14.000 --> 01:28:32.000
It hasn't gone through treatment. Yet. So what we don't see action specific gamers that would have potentially applied there, but definitely dealing with airy missions re injection of water and discharge to surface water those are all actions, specific activities, that would have associated

599
01:28:32.000 --> 01:28:50.000
Arors, alright I hope you all like that the difference in a poll with a graphic any feedback you have on it would be appreciated, but We're gonna go ahead and continue on with this question well, how do I determine, if it's applicable or relevant and appropriate because it

600
01:28:50.000 --> 01:29:05.000
All sounds the same, alright, so there's a general procedure for this you're gonna look at your potential a bars, you have to to turn out determine, if they're applicable, if not are they Relevant, and appropriate, are there tdcs that also Need to be

601
01:29:05.000 --> 01:29:20.000
Considered, in addition to the Ars, and is an aroar waiver justified in this case, so let's look at the process what we're gonna look at here is adapted from an exhibit in the EPA Guidance on Circle compliance with other Laws, Manual but

602
01:29:20.000 --> 01:29:24.000
We're trying to lay it out in an easier to understand format.

603
01:29:24.000 --> 01:29:41.000
So we're going to go ahead and start here, we're identifying the pertinent facts, concerning the situation at a site or Ou Alright, so what Type, of Substances are we looking at is it, a Special Location Who's Impacted by this Contamination do you have

604
01:29:41.000 --> 01:29:46.000
Sensitive populations to consider except what are the characteristics of the Site.

605
01:29:46.000 --> 01:29:51.000
So you gather your your information and develop that understanding of the site from there you go ahead, and review and list, provisions of each potential applicable requirement.

606
01:29:51.000 --> 01:30:18.000
So if there's certain substances, or we keep going back to the Groundwater, contemporary example With Mcl, those cans are covered is there a specific type of facility that needs to be considered or Requirements, that deal with the Census populations you might be dealing with or actions that

607
01:30:18.000 --> 01:30:28.000
Are covered. So you start trying to list out that list just based on what you, understand about the site from there, you have to compare the pertinent facts.

608
01:30:28.000 --> 01:30:48.000
About, the chemicals present, their location, and the types of action, or technology, that's under consideration for the Site, once you have all of that your Understanding of the Site and what that Might, Mean as Far as Potential Ars, go You're Going to ask yourself are all the Provisions for Requirements, Met when

609
01:30:48.000 --> 01:30:52.000
you're looking down at that section of a clean water. Act.

610
01:30:52.000 --> 01:30:57.000
It' be are all the pertinent provisions.

611
01:30:57.000 --> 01:31:01.000
Does your site check them all off like, oh, yeah, we have groundwater contamination.

612
01:31:01.000 --> 01:31:10.000
Oh, yeah, it's a source of drinking water the say, tricky, water act Mcl's apply that's just that's, the Easiest Example.

613
01:31:10.000 --> 01:31:20.000
But there are many more, if the answer is no say you have groundwater contamination, but it is not a source of potential, or actual drinking water.

614
01:31:20.000 --> 01:31:22.000
Perhaps your answer is, no, oh, okay. Well, then you would go to the procedure for determining.

615
01:31:22.000 --> 01:31:33.000
If it is relevant and appropriate. If your answer is yes, you've met all the pertinent portions of that requirement, then it's applicable.

616
01:31:33.000 --> 01:31:43.000
So that's your step one. But if you landed here in the note, you still have to determine, if something is relevant and appropriate, I saw some people asking well, what's the difference the difference.

617
01:31:43.000 --> 01:32:02.000
In it being applicable? Is that all pertinent provisions of that requirement apply to your site, they're all met so that's a big difference but they might not all be met that's why, this no look yes, step is here, so let's go.

618
01:32:02.000 --> 01:32:20.000
To the next series of steps, so say it's not applicable, but you're trying to figure out if it's relevant and appropriate, so you're going to review the factors to determine if It's Sufficiently Similar to your Site, Situation to be considered Relevant and

619
01:32:20.000 --> 01:32:38.000
appropriate, so we've mentioned these factors before the factors relating to the requirement itself, and how it relates to What's going on at your Site, so you'll look at these different criteria to help determine if it's relevant and Appropriate for Example what is

620
01:32:38.000 --> 01:32:40.000
The purpose of the program. Okay, is it to protect drinking water?

621
01:32:40.000 --> 01:33:04.000
Is it to protect sediments? Is it to what have you whatever the requirement may be, and does that apply to your site, is the use of that requirement consistent with the purpose of the regulation which entities are affected what other circumstances are are happening at your site where you say oh yeah, this

622
01:33:04.000 --> 01:33:11.000
Could be important information. It's not applicable exactly. But we should be considering this moving forward.

623
01:33:11.000 --> 01:33:15.000
So you go through all those factors, and remember it's not black and white.

624
01:33:15.000 --> 01:33:29.000
It is so mostly based on professional judgment. So if you think it's hard to figure out what a which Ars apply well, I don't blame you, because there is not just a clear answer.

625
01:33:29.000 --> 01:33:33.000
So once you're going through all this information refine that comparison.

626
01:33:33.000 --> 01:33:52.000
Really look okay, what am I dealing with at my site, what substance am I dealing with what media am I dealing with, do the circumstances of my Site and of the release, at my site really meet some of the Aspects of the Aar that you're considering from there you ask that question based on consideration of

627
01:33:52.000 --> 01:33:58.000
All these factors is the requirement, both relevant, and appropriate.

628
01:33:58.000 --> 01:34:13.000
If the answer is no, it might just be, the requirement is not relevant in aappropriate, so it's not an avar however, before you jump to that red box, consider what if you subdivided the requirement it's it that it's not meeting all the Requirements, because it's too.

629
01:34:13.000 --> 01:34:34.000
Large. Do you have the scope small enough for the specific section of that regulation you're, looking at to determine if it may be sufficiently similar to what's happening at your site, if it, is then you Start, all you start All over so if I hit it up into that smaller section and go through

630
01:34:34.000 --> 01:34:53.000
your considerations. Again, however, if you say yes, it's meeting all these factors or based on these factors, it's met a majority of them it makes sense to have this as a relevant and appropriate requirement so what does that mean let let's look at a little example where you can apply

631
01:34:53.000 --> 01:34:58.000
your understanding. we got our little graphic. Here, this is this blue line is the site.

632
01:34:58.000 --> 01:35:13.000
You can see, there's some Soil, Disturbing and Fancying activities happening here that could impact the entire Site and we know there's endangered species found in these Forested Areas, Alright Jean can you take Us through the question

633
01:35:13.000 --> 01:35:17.000
Absolutely so i'm gonna launch this poll window and there's 2 questions that we're going to ask for this particular graphic and I'll just note.

634
01:35:17.000 --> 01:35:27.000
You may need to scroll up and down in the poll window, to read the full set of options for each one.

635
01:35:27.000 --> 01:35:43.000
And if it's blocking anything that window can be moved around and also resized, just like any other application window as needed so feel free, to pick it up and drag it around and resize it as needed Alright so that first question we'll ask how should the endangered, species, act be considered for

636
01:35:43.000 --> 01:35:44.000
This site, should it be a applicable B relevant and appropriate.

637
01:35:44.000 --> 01:35:56.000
C, Tbc, or d. Should not be considered, and then if you scroll down in the pop, up, you'll see our second question what type of Aar?

638
01:35:56.000 --> 01:36:01.000
Should the endangered species act be identified? As and is it a chemical specific b location, specific or C.

639
01:36:01.000 --> 01:36:11.000
Action, specific and again, once you've clicked the circle to the left of the answer that you think is correct for each of those 2 questions.

640
01:36:11.000 --> 01:36:18.000
You can hit, the submit Button looks like almost 40% of you have sent your votes on in again, if you're having any trouble you can also just chime in your thoughts into the Q.

641
01:36:18.000 --> 01:36:26.000
And a I mean, I am starting to see some responses and feedback from your question.

642
01:36:26.000 --> 01:36:29.000
Earlier, people seem to like the picture-based questions better.

643
01:36:29.000 --> 01:36:30.000
Okay.

644
01:36:30.000 --> 01:36:31.000
So they said they, like the graphics, at least that's what I'm starting to see.

645
01:36:31.000 --> 01:36:35.000
But we'll take a look at the Feedback and confirm.

646
01:36:35.000 --> 01:36:36.000
Okay.

647
01:36:36.000 --> 01:36:39.000
That is is a consistent trend, alright It looks like about two-thirds of you have voted.

648
01:36:39.000 --> 01:36:45.000
So I'm gonna go ahead and close this poll in 3, 2, one, and let's look at those results together.

649
01:36:45.000 --> 01:37:06.000
So our first question Emmy about half of the audience. Thought it should be considered a applicable, the Endangered Species Act, but a number of people also felt, it could be relevant in appropriate and then it was sort of an overwhelming response about 83% picked location specific type of Area.

650
01:37:06.000 --> 01:37:09.000
For question 2. So what were the right answers

651
01:37:09.000 --> 01:37:10.000
So the right answers per question one, the endangered species act should be considered applicable.

652
01:37:10.000 --> 01:37:26.000
It would check off all the protein portions of the endangered species act because we have endangered species, directly next to the site.

653
01:37:26.000 --> 01:37:42.000
So question too. I think it was kind of like a gave you a hint for how to answer, question one. But the endangered species act is a Federal location-specific AR so the B would be the right answer that

654
01:37:42.000 --> 01:37:46.000
Okay. we'll go ahead. And we have one more question.

655
01:37:46.000 --> 01:38:03.000
Let's jump on the next One just for the Sake of Time. with this example, you see our Onsite Groundwater, Treatment System and effect contaminated Groundwater Extraction, Treatment and then Discharge, to Surface Water will you take us through these questions, Jean

656
01:38:03.000 --> 01:38:06.000
Absolutely so I'm about to launch the next set of questions again.

657
01:38:06.000 --> 01:38:10.000
We have 2, questions for this particular graphic, you can move it around and resize it.

658
01:38:10.000 --> 01:38:14.000
As needed. So in this case we're we have Onsite, Groundwater Treatment, and the Remedy includes direct discharge to a surface water body.

659
01:38:14.000 --> 01:38:25.000
Which Federal regulations would be considered an Aar. For this site, and in this first question you can select multiple answers.

660
01:38:25.000 --> 01:38:26.000
So you can pick one, or all that apply? Would it be a recra, B, clean water, act, c, fish, and wildlife?

661
01:38:26.000 --> 01:38:51.000
Coordination act, or D. The Wild and Scenic Rivers Act, once you've answered that question, you can scroll down to the second one which asks which sub part of the Federal Regulation identified should Be Considered an error, for this Site again, this is a Multiple choice style Questions you can pick any

662
01:38:51.000 --> 01:39:09.000
Or all and for that second question, you have option, a clean water, act, indirect, discharge requirements, b clean water, act section 400, and 4 Regarding Dredged materials we have our clean Water Act, National Pollutant Discharge, Elimination, at C and then We have D the

663
01:39:09.000 --> 01:39:11.000
Clean Water, acts section 100, and 3. On Mars Marine Protection, and I apologize.

664
01:39:11.000 --> 01:39:29.000
It was trimmed off here. I want to make sure I read that full option to them option d was the merine protection research and sanctuaries act, Regarding, ocean discharge I apologize if that one was cut off of it Alright, So once you clicked your answers and then you

665
01:39:29.000 --> 01:39:47.000
hit the Submit Button. We'll take a quick look at the responses before carrying on with our session and Emmy I'm starting to see a trend here and I think we may have tipped our Hat to the first question based on the Answers for the second Question and I

666
01:39:47.000 --> 01:39:52.000
think they're starting to pick up on that as I'm looking at the Answers coming in.

667
01:39:52.000 --> 01:40:03.000
But I see about 3, almost two-thirds have voted. So I'm gonna go ahead and close this set of questions down here, in 3 to one and Let's share those results.

668
01:40:03.000 --> 01:40:11.000
So for our first question asking which bottle regulations could become considered an er overwhelmingly.

669
01:40:11.000 --> 01:40:17.000
Everybody, picked B, the clean, water act, but about, half of the audience.

670
01:40:17.000 --> 01:40:25.000
Thought C could be fish and wildlife, Coordination act, and then a number of people. Also felt that the Wild And Scenic Rivers Act could be an a r here

671
01:40:25.000 --> 01:40:30.000
So for question, one we were looking for the clean water act.

672
01:40:30.000 --> 01:40:36.000
I I think everyone got that and see, the Fish and Well Fish Coordination acts.

673
01:40:36.000 --> 01:40:41.000
I could see if this stream fit into a wild or scenic river.

674
01:40:41.000 --> 01:40:46.000
Perhaps that could apply. As well, but we were looking for B, and C. Here

675
01:40:46.000 --> 01:40:51.000
Okay and then for that second question, it looks overwhelmingly like the audience.

676
01:40:51.000 --> 01:41:00.000
Picked, C, the Clean Water Act, National Pollutant, discharge, elimination, system, or nip. These permit requirements.

677
01:41:00.000 --> 01:41:02.000
Yes, this is a direct point of discharge to a surface water body.

678
01:41:02.000 --> 01:41:08.000
So we were looking for C, great job, everybody

679
01:41:08.000 --> 01:41:10.000
Alright.

680
01:41:10.000 --> 01:41:14.000
Okay, so I know we're quickly running out of time.

681
01:41:14.000 --> 01:41:19.000
So I am going to hit the last of our slides as the efficiently as possible to close out our course.

682
01:41:19.000 --> 01:41:37.000
So let's transition now, to points of compliance we touch on this a little bit already, but I think it's important that we go into a little more detail so with groundwater Points of Compliance again we're looking at attaining remediation levels that are established on

683
01:41:37.000 --> 01:41:59.000
Your site, specific information. Whatever those circumstances may be and also, remediation levels that are identified, Via, numerical value, that's an Mcl or other types of determined cleanup levels it needs to be aained throughout the plume or at the Boundary of a Waste Management, Area, some arguments I've

684
01:41:59.000 --> 01:42:11.000
Heard regarding this is oh, well, why should it be throughout the entire plume no one's ever gonna drink this water we're the Federal agency is going to own own the land in Perpetuity?

685
01:42:11.000 --> 01:42:31.000
So why would we spend millions upon millions of dollars to clean up this groundwater, and it's not that EPA is being difficult oftentimes EPA's Guidance and policy especially for groundwater is based on language, from the Ncp so It's we Don't, have flexibility, when I say.

686
01:42:31.000 --> 01:42:32.000
We I mean EPA is a regulatory agency.

687
01:42:32.000 --> 01:42:37.000
May not have flexibility, on what is being requested for a site.

688
01:42:37.000 --> 01:42:44.000
So that's just something to keep in mind another requirement that I just want to point out to everybody.

689
01:42:44.000 --> 01:42:49.000
Is for Federal facilities, actually, for all our super phone cleanups.

690
01:42:49.000 --> 01:42:55.000
Is the requirement, that you know Department agency, or Zealandality of the Us.

691
01:42:55.000 --> 01:43:15.000
Can adopt guidelines, rules, or regulations, or criteria, which are inconsistent with the Guidelines, rules, and regulations of EPA so that is that is Required to be met and again, that' does not allow for flexibility and flexibility and its interpretation so coming back

692
01:43:15.000 --> 01:43:19.000
To groundwater the reasons why it has to be attained throughout the plume.

693
01:43:19.000 --> 01:43:40.000
And again, knowing that different areas of the flu might reach remediation levels at different times, you're leading it versus the Upgrading Area, near the source, you might not all have the same timeframe across the place with surface, water pocs We're looking at those Levels, that should be attained at

694
01:43:40.000 --> 01:43:41.000
The point of release, that point of discharge. Very easy to identify.

695
01:43:41.000 --> 01:44:02.000
Just like we did in our sample question a little while ago, and Air Pocs when you're looking at selecting those levels for the maximum Exposed individual Considering the Use of the Site, in the Surrounding Area Or their Houses, Nearby is it commercial Areas, it are their schools or Daycares.

696
01:44:02.000 --> 01:44:11.000
As Ddr mentioned, do you have to work with your Department of Health with the Air emissions to identify what those levels should look like. Likely.

697
01:44:11.000 --> 01:44:21.000
So so if you're doing anything like excavation, incineration, or even airstripping in your groundwater, treatment, then you need to look at those emissions.

698
01:44:21.000 --> 01:44:27.000
Now what everyone I think might be excited to talk about are circular Arrow Waivers.

699
01:44:27.000 --> 01:44:44.000
So section 1, 21, d. Of Surplo requires that Onsite Remedial Actions, either attain or wave a bars upon completion and We've already mentioned, that off-site Activities have To comply with both Substantive and Administrative Requirements if They're Off

700
01:44:44.000 --> 01:44:45.000
Site, the Statutory Requirement, that a remedy be Protective, cannot be.

701
01:44:45.000 --> 01:45:00.000
Wait like that cannot go away, but when it comes to a waiver, you have to invoke, a waiver, for each a bar that will not be attained.

702
01:45:00.000 --> 01:45:04.000
It's not just a Blank ticket to not meet multiple ars.

703
01:45:04.000 --> 01:45:09.000
Each one has to be consistent separately, with documentation of waivers.

704
01:45:09.000 --> 01:45:29.000
You need to have in your circle of proposed plan, a summary explanation of why the Waivers being proposed and also allow for public comment to happen on that proposed Waiver and it's, justification the public needs the opportunity to Weigh in on that and once say it is approved in

705
01:45:29.000 --> 01:45:41.000
The Rod that justification needs to be explained in detail and the specific Waiver invoked for that specific right requirement should be explained.

706
01:45:41.000 --> 01:45:45.000
So there are 6, avar waivers, but for Federal facilities.

707
01:45:45.000 --> 01:45:48.000
We look at the first 5

708
01:45:48.000 --> 01:45:54.000
Really I'm gonna go ahead and skip the group poll, just for the Sake of Time, sorry about that.

709
01:45:54.000 --> 01:46:00.000
Oh, so interim measures, I would say, this is one of the most used aira waivers.

710
01:46:00.000 --> 01:46:05.000
If you have an intim remedial action, you can say, okay, this is a initial. Action.

711
01:46:05.000 --> 01:46:24.000
We're not going to attain Mcl's, but it will help reduce contaminant concentrations, or it will help with controlling the flow of groundwater to support a future remedial action so perhaps you're not Going to meet mcl for this pump and treat

712
01:46:24.000 --> 01:46:28.000
Remedy selected for a hot zone in a groundwater plume.

713
01:46:28.000 --> 01:46:33.000
If it's an instrument, interim measure and there will be a final rod that will meet.

714
01:46:33.000 --> 01:46:54.000
For Example Mcl's in the future, you can explain that in your in your document, but again, this should all be in line with the site plan for the Cleanup of the entire system we also have the greater risk waiver, I have only seen this use 2, times, in the history, of the Federal Facilities, program, and

715
01:46:54.000 --> 01:47:06.000
This is when complying with a requirement, would actually result in greater risk to human health in the environment, including workers, site workers, then other alternative options.

716
01:47:06.000 --> 01:47:27.000
So the example. Here is one of the 2 that I mentioned, say Conducting Land disposal requirements to treat waste before it's put into a disposal cell, might actually result in greater risk if You're dealing with very large heavily Contaminated radiological Contamination at a Site so if

717
01:47:27.000 --> 01:47:35.000
you could put it in the cell and treat it there, that actually would reduce risk to workers so that's one example, also technical impracticability.

718
01:47:35.000 --> 01:47:44.000
This is, what I think. People talk about the most say oh, EPA never issues.

719
01:47:44.000 --> 01:47:45.000
Those waivers. You're never gonna get one don't even try that's not exactly true, we do issue.

720
01:47:45.000 --> 01:48:02.000
Them, each region has issued one or more Ti waivers, and what it really is saying is that compliance with the requirement is technically impracticable from an engineering perspective now cost may be considered.

721
01:48:02.000 --> 01:48:17.000
As part of this but it can't be the sole reason and I think that's where a lot of arguments between regulatory agencies and the cleanup agencies happen so it might be, that there's no existing or innovative technologies that can actually Address the

722
01:48:17.000 --> 01:48:35.000
Contamination to attain that a word, question, or doing, so would be illogical or infeasible from an engineering perspective, like Dean, apple situations in cracked Bedrock where you just can't get to it that might be an example of where it's just illogical or

723
01:48:35.000 --> 01:48:38.000
infeasible to get to

724
01:48:38.000 --> 01:48:46.000
Equivalent standard of performance, this is when say, the reg identifies a specific standard of performance.

725
01:48:46.000 --> 01:48:51.000
But there may be an equivalent one that would be just as if not more.

726
01:48:51.000 --> 01:49:01.000
Protective or effective, that is but when you would consider this standard with that one thing to keep in mind.

727
01:49:01.000 --> 01:49:19.000
If a State has inconsistently applied a requirement across its sites, then there, is a potential argument that could be made that it should not have to apply under this specific remedy if that again, if it's cherry-picked only some sites have complied with it other Sites

728
01:49:19.000 --> 01:49:25.000
Have the head not to comply with it, then that could be justification for a waiver.

729
01:49:25.000 --> 01:49:31.000
I want to share some interesting information just to show you that I I am serious.

730
01:49:31.000 --> 01:49:32.000
We have had over the years, a number of Arab waivers issued at our Federal facilities.

731
01:49:32.000 --> 01:49:40.000
This is looking at 1,992 to 2,020, based on EPA's Sims, information, our superflu enterprise management.

732
01:49:40.000 --> 01:50:06.000
System, so you could see in the Ninetys we had quite a number, being issued a little less, so for after 2,000, and 13, some other information here Technical and practicalability what and an Interim Action where the most used waivers, greater risk there were 2 and equivalent Performance we've Issued

733
01:50:06.000 --> 01:50:22.000
4. When I say, we I mean the EPA better facilities program this does not include private sites, so those would be different numbers looking at waivers by region, we can see here that each almost each region has had okay, I I Misspoke earlier not every region has issued one in the Federal facilities.

734
01:50:22.000 --> 01:50:33.000
Program, but several have and that is just showing you really quick, we've had the most so far.

735
01:50:33.000 --> 01:50:42.000
In region, 4, and in region, 2. Alright off to you. Dj.

736
01:50:42.000 --> 01:50:48.000
Alright we're gonna make our time. I promise. Alright, I'm gonna talk about Arizona.

737
01:50:48.000 --> 01:51:07.000
So freezing ars in a rod, if you have a newly promulgated requirement, that may leave your Protective Newness in question, then this these are some of the things that you should think about and as an example maybe and it hasn't been done yet I don't want to be clear about that

738
01:51:07.000 --> 01:51:24.000
but there's talk about the Lead Number being lowered it's just talk right now, but in this, you know, this can happen with pfas if we ever you know, come up with a Mcl for that but at any rate, anytime you're protectiveness is maybe maybe

739
01:51:24.000 --> 01:51:33.000
not protective, any longer? These are some of the things you can do so you need to evaluate it, and see if the remedy remains protective.

740
01:51:33.000 --> 01:51:47.000
When you have this newly propagated requirement, say, if they lower the lead number, and if if it's not protected, you have to go and look at the risk based on the new number then you'll have to go back in and Evaluate, you know the protection, at different you know

741
01:51:47.000 --> 01:51:49.000
Where did it say? They lowered it from 400 to 200.

742
01:51:49.000 --> 01:52:06.000
I don't know that that's gonna happen. But then if anything is between the 200 400 number you're gonna have to go back in and evaluate, those sites and apply the newly Promulgated Requirement but if nothing is Everything's Below 200, the New

743
01:52:06.000 --> 01:52:12.000
Number then you would call them frozen and everything would be fine, and your your remedy would still remain protective.

744
01:52:12.000 --> 01:52:30.000
But the remedy must be modified if a new err is needed to to remain protective, and this can be captured in the Explanation of Significant Differences or in a rod amendment depending on the Scope of how large the action that is needed for your specific site

745
01:52:30.000 --> 01:52:35.000
And I can give you an example. My Us. Private site, that I have exact.

746
01:52:35.000 --> 01:52:39.000
When the tenants moved into the building, then our need change.

747
01:52:39.000 --> 01:52:40.000
Now, this is an avar specific need, except that we did have to figure out a our number site.

748
01:52:40.000 --> 01:53:01.000
Specific numbers for the Vi risk to the tenants in the slides. I have a vapor, Mitigation alternative inside the building, and I also have an Sbe system which is pulling out the papers from underneath the building, to ensure protectiveness throughout the Remaining Action until

749
01:53:01.000 --> 01:53:08.000
We have the Site Embedded Completely from Medial Investment standpoint

750
01:53:08.000 --> 01:53:15.000
So ars and 5, Year Reviews and This is another big 5 year reviews, is another big red flag.

751
01:53:15.000 --> 01:53:32.000
If you have something that needs to be changed. And that's I love 5 year reviews, because it recalls for your review of a site, and if anything is changed, if you notice there's bi or you noticed that a number has changed and sometimes actually the like I just found out from South carolina that they raise

752
01:53:32.000 --> 01:53:39.000
Their vi number from one rod to another on the same site, and so we're talking about you know, looking into that in the future, so it can go either.

753
01:53:39.000 --> 01:53:44.000
Way, but you know we'd have to have a reason to reopen the esd.

754
01:53:44.000 --> 01:54:02.000
But you know to reopen it, and and considering esd, but any kind of change and if I your view actually that it's the common occurrence, that you have to go in and look at something differently evaluate protectiveness standards or you know, something changed a wetland, I mean any

755
01:54:02.000 --> 01:54:20.000
Kind of change can influence when you reopen, your your decision, document, some of the Questions, you'll ask during the 5 year, Review is your is your remedy Functioning as it was intended are your exposure assumptions still valid do you have a new exposure like a

756
01:54:20.000 --> 01:54:25.000
Vi, path, do you have our contaminants now being introduced to a stream that weren't Previously then your toxicity and clean up levels.

757
01:54:25.000 --> 01:54:30.000
Had they changed have your remedial Action, objective?

758
01:54:30.000 --> 01:54:35.000
Have they been met. Has it been cleaned up in the time.

759
01:54:35.000 --> 01:54:38.000
Period you you initially, thought and You're Rod.

760
01:54:38.000 --> 01:54:44.000
If not, you may need to reevaluate your technologies and get a more aggressive technology, in place.

761
01:54:44.000 --> 01:54:48.000
So you look at all, the the different things and you have to decide.

762
01:54:48.000 --> 01:54:49.000
If they're still valid from a protectiveness standpoint, and then that necessitates your review of your ars, and so it 5 year Reviews are an opportunity to ensure protectiveness, and gives you an Opportunity to evaluate the implementation, and performance of your

763
01:54:49.000 --> 01:55:04.000
Er that close this out

764
01:55:04.000 --> 01:55:22.000
Remedies. And then you know. Then any new information comes, then that's additional that you'll have to look at their remedies, and maybe change some arors or in or just you noted that you've changed the a that you've investigated, a bars and no change was necessary

765
01:55:22.000 --> 01:55:27.000
And we thank you all for participating and being part of our course.

766
01:55:27.000 --> 01:55:28.000
And Emmy is the best instructor ever she developed this course so

767
01:55:28.000 --> 01:55:29.000
Thanks deidre. So we have our contact information on screen I know there were a number of questions we couldn't get to today.

768
01:55:29.000 --> 01:55:30.000
If you'd like to reach out to me or Deedra separately, with a question, just to understand the content better, please feel free to reach out we're happy to answer questions and I did want to address something very Quickly.

769
01:55:30.000 --> 01:55:31.000
I think earlier, I may have Missedpoke, and said Nepa, when I meant to reference the national Preservation historic act as being an err, so apologies for that Usually the Lead Cleanup Agency, is Responsible.

770
01:55:31.000 --> 01:56:01.000
For considering Nepa and They'll do that parallel to the Circle Process. So Apologies, if I Misspoke on that one, okay, Jean, I think We're We're done.

771
01:56:13.000 --> 01:56:17.000
I think we are emmy So with that I'm gonna have those slides stay up there for just one quick second, while I swap out the view.

772
01:56:17.000 --> 01:56:24.000
And then I'll walk through final closing reminders, for everyone.

773
01:56:24.000 --> 01:56:35.000
So I do want to echo your thanks to our speakers, and the audience who joined us for today's broadcast I do have just a couple of real quick reminders I'll get through before we close things out.

774
01:56:35.000 --> 01:56:46.000
But I want to make sure that everybody has a chance to copy down your contact information if they haven't in case, they wanted to follow up with any other questions that we may not have had time to address during our session today.

775
01:56:46.000 --> 01:57:04.000
So with that I wanted to just remind everybody that we are wrapping up the eleventh and final online Webinar that is part of the Federal Facilities online Academy, the preceding 10 webinars which were already delayed this year are currently Archived and available to play for on-demand

776
01:57:04.000 --> 01:57:08.000
Replay on a cleanup, Information network or cluan, Org Site.

777
01:57:08.000 --> 01:57:21.000
So if you missed any of the earlier 10 sessions, you can replay those this session will be ourived shortly in about one or 2 weeks, will and about one week, we'll have that recording up, so you can replay the entire series or point colleagues to it if you would like to

778
01:57:21.000 --> 01:57:35.000
Share this information, I do want to just remind everybody, if you haven't visit us at the Cleanup Information Network at Kluen Org I Encourage you to do so and please be sure to sign up for our Free Monthly Newsletter tech, direct which I send out on the first of each Month that

779
01:57:35.000 --> 01:57:38.000
Contains, Information, Related to Cleaning up hazardous Wastes.

780
01:57:38.000 --> 01:57:45.000
So we, Highlight related websites, publications, and both in-person and online training opportunities.

781
01:57:45.000 --> 01:58:00.000
The other thing to point out is that if you're looking for that participant manual, or collection of related resources, all of that information, is contained here on the Seminar Homepage so at homepage is shown in red on this URL it is active from today, Forward so even if You're, watching a

782
01:58:00.000 --> 01:58:07.000
Recorded version you can visit that you URL, to access materials and I'll just remind everyone that content is broken up in these little gray sections.

783
01:58:07.000 --> 01:58:08.000
So you may need to scroll up and down, and use the plus and minus.

784
01:58:08.000 --> 01:58:25.000
Icons, to expand or collapse each. Section. But you will find the webinar slides are posted here as a file, known as the Participant Manual, which contains not only the Slides, but related, notes and then we do have a Whole Collection, of Related Websites, on Today's Topic that have also been

785
01:58:25.000 --> 01:58:40.000
Posted now, if you would like to get a participate based off of your joining today's webinar, I'll ask you to fill out the online, feedback form that feedback, form can be found on the seminar homepage so it's, one of the last Sections so you can visit

786
01:58:40.000 --> 01:58:54.000
This seminar homepage, and fill out that online feedback form please make sure that you fill out your email address and check the box on that form certifying you were here for the entire session, and then as soon as you send your feedback in you'll have access to download, or print out, a

787
01:58:54.000 --> 01:59:07.000
Participation, certificate we'll also email, a copy to you, but sometimes spam or junk filters, catch those Emails, so I, encourage you to download it from the Confirmation, screen, as soon, as you, see it, if you, happen to join a viewing party or others, joined you at your

788
01:59:07.000 --> 01:59:10.000
Location, even if they didn't register on their own if you get them.

789
01:59:10.000 --> 01:59:22.000
The link to that some of our homepage they can give us their feedback, even though they didn't register individually, and get their own participation, certificate, so I encourage you to share, that URL if you were the one who registered so that those who joined you can also share their

790
01:59:22.000 --> 01:59:37.000
Thoughts, to get their own certificates. And if you happen to be one of the lucky ones, replaying today's Archive right around now in the Archive, there should be a Button just above my head in the upper right that has a link to that feedback, form so you should be able to

791
01:59:37.000 --> 01:59:44.000
click, that and open up the same feedback form. Give us your feedback based off of replaying the Recorded Version, making sure you check the box certifying that.

792
01:59:44.000 --> 01:59:45.000
You did that, and then you can still get a participation.

793
01:59:45.000 --> 01:59:49.000
Certificate for your own records, based off, your replay.

794
01:59:49.000 --> 02:00:00.000
So with that I want to thank Emmy and All of her Instructors, as well, as the Over 250 individuals who joined us for Today's Live Broadcast we hope that you found this to be a valuable expenditure, of your time and you will join us on a future

795
02:00:00.000 --> 02:00:03.000
Seminar. Thank you. So very much for joining us.

796
02:00:03.000 --> 02:00:04.000
I'm just 3 day Class

797
02:00:04.000 --> 02:00:29.000
This will be the formal conclusion, and the 3 in Class That's right there'll be additional details posted on a separate site for those of you, who registered and participated in the online Webinars, so Thank you Deja for that Reminder when with that we'll go Ahead and Formally conclude

798
02:00:29.000 --> 02:00:39.000
Okay.